PERMFILE126366 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

in the non winter months. Use in the warmer months will be the most irrvasive to the residents, as that is when people attempt to sleep with windows opeq and spead more time outdoors. The opening of this valley amrs directly at homes sitvate8 in the Ward Creek Valley or on Elie ridge du~ectly west of (here.lVoise and dust from the operation will adversely affect these residences. Also, noise and dust from fhe crusher operatedhy i<ce Belden affected residences both north and south of fhe Belden shale pit. Although flie shale pit is not visr~ite from these residences the noise was reffected-off the canyon walls. This operation was quite minimaCwmpared to what is tolie expected-from this new development. There are at least IZ residences up valley wltlilu'/. mile of the operation whicfi will-not see the operation but wlii fiear ii. it is reasonable to assume that residences hi direct line of sigh"t of the operatiion will be affected 1iy noise. As descn`tied earlier, there are at least 69 residences wliioh fallurto this category. `Itiat makes about 81 residences whioli can expect significant impact firm noise and/or dust. Y9rere is no way to satisfactorily mitigate these impacts. "remoteness of the location" Area is not at all remote. The operation will fie directly visible to at least 20 residences located with'h mile south of the ridge top , at least 4 residences located withia'/~ mile to the west of the operation, and at least 42 residences located between''/z and 1 % miles to the northwest. There are 3 residences located directly to the north in sight ofthe operation. There are at least i2 residences up valley within'/, mile of the operation which will not see the operation but will hear it. It is reasonable to assume that residences in direct line of sight ofthe operation will be affected by noise. As described earlier, there are at least 69 residences which fall into this category. That makes about 81 residences which can expect significant impact from noise and dust. On a topographic map of the area I have located 2b residences within 1/4 mile of the site, 44 residences within % mile, and 78 residences within'/, mile of the site. A partial ta11y of residences within 2-1/4 miles of the site brings the count to 195, but this is probably only about 213 of the actual total. This is a rather densely populated area, and this development is in no way compatible with adjacent land uses. Note that the heavy truck traffic, and noise from joke brakes, will affect many more residences up and down the valley than I have tallied here. High ridges on three sides will reduce the effects of noise and dust: The Belden crushing operation in the same valley has produced considerable noise and dust annoyance to the neighbors, and the proposed Benson operation will be much larger. Estimates from Benson Brothers of 85 decibels of noise 500 feet from the cnusher is not compatible with this residential area. We were unable to get an estimate of generator noise anticipated. Note that the racket of bulldozing of material from high on the south ridge of the valley and the backup alarms associated with the same will be part of the operations. The operator is not planning to mist the bulldozing operation to reduce dust clouds. It is expected that this activity will release the most particulate matter of the whole operation. Watering the road: may control dust from truck traffic, and misting the crusher (as promised by Bensons) may help with dust from that operation, but direct communication with the Benson brothers indicates that they cannot control the dust from removal of material from the slopes. This will in fact be a major cause of dust.