WSP01328

• File Number: 8030
• Description: Section "D" General Correspondence - Other Organizations/Agencies ‎(Alpha, not Basin Related)‎
• Date: 12/21/1971
• Author: WRC
• Title: Proposed Principles and Standards for Planning Water and Related Land Resources-Notice of Public Hearing, Water Resources Council
• Water Supply Pro - Doc Type: Publication

sce.le included in Plan E intended to serve
the regtona.l development obje<1tlve:

Marginal benll-
fiLa andcCX!lts
of Il.IternaUve
USOl! or rllSourcl'tlo
r~qulred for
P!Q.D.E

-pm-
mended Dl:I'!er-
PlanE enc.e

NED obJective:
B"lDefitIL___.___n
Costs________
Net benefit!_n___

"30
130
o

$100 -$30
130 0
-30 -30

Thus:
Gross l.iiCremeDJta.l NED costs = e30
Net 1JlorementeJ. NED costs ~ $30
2. Rem&lntng jotnt NED 006t.s of Pl.a.n E;
Tote.1 NED costa ot Plan E_u________ f130
Less not tn.orement&1 NED costa of
Plan E____________________________ -SO

Bemainl.ng joint NED costs of Plan EL_ 100
3. NED coat aJ1o:Btton t.able tor Plan E tor
obJect:.tve8:

ObJectlve
NED Eq RD

Totel

L Bone1its__._________ '"'' (Qual. '176 r)
It~
tlve)
:I. Alterna.tlve NED
c03ts_______.un____ U30 $130 $130 (')
3. Honeflullmlt{\(L.__.__ 1100 r) '$30 $130
4.. Net Incremental NED
cOllts._______.____n_u_ \') i') $30 $30
II. Remalnlng beneft18____ 100 ') 0 "00
Percent dbtrlbutlon_n_ 100 P) 0 .)'00
do Remll.inJng Joinl,NED
cosl.ll____.__n___..__n_ .$100 (') 0 '100
1. Toto.l ellocatad NED "30
COStl!l__._n_______._n__ 1100 (') '30

I Not eppUco.ble. ""
I Benefits tQ the EQ oblocUv~ Incld.ental to Plan B,
thus no NED C'.OSI.lI to be allocel.eCl to th19 obJective.
. Benefits UmHell by amount 01 grOS'l and net Incn-
mental NED cost:!. In th1scaae It b 889umed tbe relrlonal
devtI]opment Det benellt& assocIated with Plan E 11.1:.
wortb at least $30 NED cost!. " "
C. AUooa.tion. 0/ NED Colt, Among (Jom-
pcnent:J 01 NED Objective..
1. NED cost allocation table fur Plan E for
Nli:D OOmponenta:

NED component
1m. Eeer&- Power
gatlon atlou

Total

"1. Bwefl.tLn__________ 1150 '20 $30 0100
l'et'C8Ilt distribution__ 50 20 30 100
2. Total allocated NED 1100
eosta________._______._ 1150 $20 130

oase 5--IncrementaJ. scaJe lnolUd.ed. in p1aD.
Intended. prlm&r1lY ttJ Berve the env1.rol:l.-
Jl18ntaJ. quaJ1lt.y ob]oot.1V'8 a.nd 1ncnmlentBl
808.le included In pl!l.2llntended. prtmarily iO
serve the reg10naJ development objecUvEJ.

A.. Project Data:

JilED objective: Recommended
Beneflcta.1 'elIe0t8: Plan. F
Flood control_ _ $50
Itttga.t1OJJ. _____ '10
Recreation ____ 30
power ________ 40
External eoom-
oin1es ____ 10

Total n__~_. 200

NOTICES

Adverse effects:
Adverse effeots:
Project con.
struct10n and
OM&R ______
External dl.8-
econom1es ___

Total _._____
Net beneflclal of.
tecta ______nn_
EQ objective:
Beneftc1al and ad-
verse effects.

RD objective:
Income:
Bene11cial effootB:
:Fe ____________
In1ga.tlon. ":'nn
RecreartJ.on ____
"Power _________
ExternaJ. econo-
mies,
Unemployed. re-
saureee,
Addlto1.onal net
1ncom.e 00-
cT'Ulng to
regIon.

Total __n___
Income:
Adverse effects:
Reimburse.
ment.
External dis-
economioo.
Loss at ass1st-
o.nce pay-
ments.
LoBs of net tn.
come In ;roe.
glan.

Total ___nn__
" Net beneficial e:f.
recta,
Emptoyment:
B~neOcia1 etrects_

Adverse e:lfects_n
Net beneficial ef-
tects.

,Regional economic
base and sta-
bwty:
BeneO.cllld 8Dd ad-
verse e1fectB.

,..
.
160

so

1. MeerlBSta.rteW'8/telr
qua.t1ty standanl6
over 100 miles
stream.
2. 5,000 acres flat
wa.ter.
3. Create 60,000
acres green space.
4,. Inundate 16
mIles free flowing
st.reoms,
5. Inundate 6
miles free ftow1ng
streams perlod.1-
ClSJJ:y."
6. Dest:roy 50,000
a.cres of desert.

$.0
70
,.
40
10

40

lao

3'.

$70
.

I.

,20

1I0
2"

1. Orea.to 320 farm
opemtion jobs.
2. Create 1,500 other
lobs.
3. Crea.te 400 jobs
tor 4 years.
1. Loss of 200 jobs.
1. Create 320 tarm
operation Jobs.
~. Create 1,300
othet' Jobs.
S. Create 400 jobs
tor 4 yea.rs.

1. Create. 320 new
family aize tarma.
2. Create 1,200 tull.
ttme medium m-
coane jobs.

24187

3. crea.te 400 medi-
um Income jobs
tor 4 years.
4,. Create 300 low
pa.l.d seasonal jObS:

Recreational oppor~
tun1ties:
Be:ne:ilotaI and ad-
verso effects.

1. Create diversity
of recrea.ttona.1. op-
portun:lty includ-
1n.g:
a. 7,500 IJUl,n-days
boating:
b. 3.800 man-days
fisbing;
c. 20,000 man-
. days picnickIng.

EQ of eped8il re~
gtona! oonoern:
Beneficial and ad~
verse effects.

1. Mf'e.ts Sta to
water quality
standards over 50
mJles stren.m..
2. 5.000 acres flat
water.
3. Orea te 50,000
acres green 6pa.ce.
4. Inundate 16
m11es free flowing
stream.
6. Inundate 6 mUes
tree _ flowln~
stream pertodl~
cally.
6. Destroy" 50,000
acres ot desert.

Social tactors:
BeneDc1al and
verse ef!ects.

ad-

1. 42-year flood pro~
teotlon to clty_'
2. Provision ot 50
MW hydropower
capacity centrally
located in region
not dependent
upon importation
and movement ot
fuel.
Costs AmO'niJ Ob~

B. Allocation 0/ NED
lective.s.
1. InerementaJ. NED costs and Incidental
incremental NED benefits associated wtth In-
cremental scale t.ncluded in Plan Ii' intended.
to serve the environmental quallty objectIVe
(:reservoir capacity tor -downstream lo:w OoW"
augmentation) :

Recommanded
pleD with
secvtceto EQ
objective
deleted

Recom-
mended Differ-
Plan F ence

NED obJective:
Benefits;
Recreatlon_
POWBr______.
Otber_.__._______
TotaL______:__
C09t.s___~__

'20
30
130

$30 __.___d
fO___..___
130.____h_
200 -..--$20
160 '"

ISO
110

Thus:
Gr088 Incremental NED oo5ta=f40
Net t.n.crementaJ. NED c08ts=$20
2. Incremental NED costs and IncldentaJ.
incremental NED benefits a.ssoc:I.a.ted. With tn-
orem.e'Il.ta.I acaJe lnoIuded in P1&n F lntended.
to serve bhe regional. development objectJve
(reservoir ca.p8C1t.y, distribution system and
pump 11ft / to serve benchlanda not 1ncr&-
mentally econOlll.lcaJ1y Justlfl.ed):

FEDERAL REGISTER, VOL 36, NO. 245_TUESDAY, DECEMBER 21, 1971