|
<br />24186
<br />
<br />Objectives:
<br />1. Incremental NED cOsts and. lnc1dentaJ.
<br />1ncremDD.taJ. NED benefits e.ssocle.ted with
<br />feature inclUded. in recommended plan ope:r-
<br />ated to serve tho environmental qUattty ob-
<br />Jectlve "(reservoir cape.ctty for downstream
<br />ICY'll flow &\18IIlentat1on):
<br />
<br />Recommended
<br />plan wlth
<br />lllrV1cet.oEQ
<br />objective
<br />deleted
<br />
<br />Recom-
<br />mended DUIeronco
<br />PllUlD
<br />
<br />NED obJective.: $120 $100 -$20
<br />Benefit:ln________
<br />Costs___________ 90 80 -10
<br />Net benefits______ 80 20 -10
<br />
<br />NOTB: In th18 CM8 8J:ample ~ has beeG1
<br />assumed. tJ:l.a't in the absence at' providing
<br />service to the EQ objective the power and
<br />recreation oomponen"Ui would. be sroled with-
<br />in the" plan to JJ1fl,Xim1ze net; NED beneflt8.
<br />As shown above, add1tlonallncrem.enbal NED
<br />coote for spedflo power and recreation fa-
<br />clUtles to ma.x1mdZe these net benefits 18
<br />assumed 1:10 be elO under a.n alternatIve Opel'-
<br />atlng pla.:n where no provision is made for low
<br />flow releases. IncrementoJ NED benefits tor
<br />power and recreation is assumed.' to be ,20
<br />under croeh e.:n uternatlve operating
<br />~ment.
<br />A fUrther Lmplled assumptIon In this ease
<br />example 1s that it Is more EtIlclent to forego
<br />power and recrea.tlon net benefits tha.n It
<br />. would be to lLdd addlttonaJ. co.po.clty In the
<br />reservotr to make low flow releasee beyond
<br />that which ma.x1m1ZeB power and recrea.tion
<br />net NED benefits. This may frequently be the
<br />case, 1.e, to lnaease reservoIr capacity beyond
<br />that a.ssumed for eIther alternative opera.ting
<br />a.rrangement. would be very C08tly due to, for
<br />exam.ple. major road, railroad, or bridge
<br />relocations.
<br />In this s1tuo.tIori where the recommended
<br />multlobjectlve plan does not rcproocnt 'the
<br />inclusion of' Increment8 ot soaJe tor the EQ
<br />or the RD objeot.lve to a plan which has
<br />been scaled. to maxl.m.lze net NED benefits,
<br />but ra.ther becauae of emclency considera.-
<br />tions Involves a tradeoff between net NED
<br />benefit8 and oontr'ibutlons to the EQ or the
<br />BD objectIve, the concept of gross tn.cre.
<br />menW <Xl&t,s a.n.d net Inmemental costs h68
<br />to be Viewed In tenns of net NED benefits
<br />toreg<me,
<br />
<br />Thus:
<br />Gross Incremen tn.l NED COB ts = $10
<br />Net lncren1.entaJ NED C06t&--$lO
<br />
<br />2. Remaining Joint NED OQ6ts of Plan D:
<br />
<br />Total NED coote of Plan D______________ $aO
<br />Lem net tncrementaJ. NED 006ta Plan D__ -10
<br />
<br />Rema.l.nlng Joint NED costS of Plan D___ 70
<br />
<br />3. NED C06t allceatron table tor Plan D tor
<br />objectlvel!l:
<br />
<br />OhJElCtlve
<br />NED EQ RD
<br />
<br />Tota!
<br />
<br />1, Benellts..u____un___.. $100 (0 $106 (')
<br />2, Alteroatlve NED eosls__ '" 1$15 $80 (')
<br />3, Benefl.ts Umlt"ld_________ 1M t$IO (') $90
<br />4. Net Incremental NED
<br /> ('osts...u___u_..________ ~) $10 ~) $10
<br />5. Rewal11logbeoe1lts._.___ $80 0 (') .so
<br /> rercont distributlon______ 100 0 (' 100
<br />" newalnJng Joint NED
<br /> cost!___________n________ $70 0 (') $70
<br />7. TotnJ. allocated NED
<br /> costs__._____n._.__._____ $20 $10 (') $80
<br />
<br />1 WQ standards 100 mlles.
<br />i Not appUCl~blfl.
<br />I NED costs or treatment at the lIource adequate to
<br />meet water Quallty atandarda over 100 mlles of atrOOIlL
<br />. Benafitll llm!ted by lUllount of gI'U!Il!I increment.al
<br />NED costs ..Weh are the !lame ~ net Incremental NED
<br />
<br />NOTICES
<br />
<br />C. AZlocation 0/ NED Ocwh Among Oom.
<br />pone-fiR 01 NED Objective.
<br />L Bepa.rable NED costs for NED compo--
<br />nents:
<br />
<br />Plan D
<br />Plan D PlaD D wlt.b reo-
<br />w1tb.FC reat10n
<br />omitted omltlOO
<br />
<br />Plan D
<br />with
<br />pow",
<br />omitted
<br />
<br />-',
<br />
<br />$00
<br />
<br />BD objectfve:
<br />Inco~:
<br />Benefte1a1 etreets:
<br />Irrtga.tlon ____.
<br />Recn3atton ____
<br />Power ___:..____
<br />Additional :net
<br />income Be.
<br />cru1ng to
<br />region ____
<br />
<br />Total _______
<br />Adverse effects:
<br />Relmbursement _
<br />Net benefIctal ef.
<br />
<br />fects ___________
<br />Employment:
<br />Beneflda1 and ad.
<br />verse efl'ecte.
<br />
<br />Total NED eCllIta. $80
<br />
<br />$7&
<br />
<br />Regional economic
<br />b8S!l and Bta-
<br />bll1ty:
<br />Beneft.clal and ad-
<br />verse effect8.
<br />
<br />RecTee.ttonal oppor.
<br />1nm:IJtles:
<br />Benef1oia1 and. 00-
<br />verse e:l'Iecte.
<br />
<br />EQ of specta.1 re-
<br />gt.onal concern:
<br />Ben.eftclBJ. and ad.
<br />verse effecm,
<br />
<br />SoctaJ factors:
<br />Beneftc1aJ. e.nd &4.
<br />verse effeote.
<br />
<br />f60
<br />,.
<br />20
<br />
<br />so
<br />
<br />17'
<br />
<br />60
<br />116
<br />
<br />1. Crea.te 320 fs.rm.
<br />operaMon jobe.
<br />2. Create 800 other
<br />jObS.
<br />
<br />1. Oreate 320 new
<br />'famlly sLzed
<br />fal1ll8.
<br />2, Create . 500 full-
<br />tlme medium In.
<br />"come jobe.
<br />3. create 300 low
<br />paid .seasonal
<br />jobs,
<br />
<br />1. Crea.te dlvers1Jty
<br />of recreattona1
<br />opportunity in.
<br />eluding:
<br />... 7,500 ma.n-da.ys
<br />bo8iting;
<br />b. a,800 man.(fa.ys
<br />fishing:
<br />c. 20,000 man.da.ys
<br />picnickIng.
<br />
<br />1. 3,000 e.creB flait
<br />wateir.
<br />2. CreAts 60,000
<br />aores green spa.ce.
<br />3. Inundate 10
<br />miles free flowIng
<br />stream,
<br />.... Destroy '60,000
<br />acres of desel;"t,
<br />
<br />1, Plan has dts-
<br />rtribu1l1on of net
<br />regtonsJ. income
<br />benefic1BJ. e:l'Iects
<br />by moome cl8.5lJ
<br />over :fIrst 20 years
<br />of operation. 8B
<br />follows:
<br />
<br />Income claM
<br />(dollBI"9)
<br />
<br />Percentage
<br />net bone-
<br />fiulnclass
<br />
<br />P(\!centago
<br />oladJwt{'d
<br />,,=
<br />lu('ome'
<br />In class
<br />
<br />LM8 than 3,000.__
<br />3,OO:>-I0,OOO.nn__
<br />Moretbanl0,(O)..
<br />
<br />11
<br />6~
<br />'ZI
<br />
<br />22
<br />"
<br />"
<br />
<br />2. Provjslon of 50
<br />MW hydropoWer
<br />ceJp(L01ty cenrtrally
<br />1oca.ted :in regton
<br />Dot depeDden~
<br />upon bnporliat1Dn
<br />and movement of
<br />fuel.
<br />B. Allocation. 01 NED C08t, Among
<br />Objectt1HUl.
<br />1. Incr6Dl1mIt&l NED eoets and lI.nC1dental
<br />1ncremental NED benefits associated with
<br />
<br />FEDERAL REGISTER, VOL. 36, NO, 24S-TUESDAY, DECEMBER 21, 1971
<br />
<br />$'XI
<br />
<br />separab16 N8D C08ta
<br />Plood control_______~__._______________ f10
<br />~reatLon ___________________________ 6
<br />Power ________________________________ 20
<br />
<br />To~__________~---------------- 35
<br />
<br />2. RemaInIng JolM NED costs of NED
<br />objective: .
<br />
<br />Total NED costs' aJloca.ted w NED ob-
<br />jective ___...:______:.__________________ .70
<br />Less wtal separable NED costs far NED
<br />componenta ___.___________________ -3fi
<br />
<br />Rema1Di1..ng jotnt NED costB at NED ob- '
<br />jectlve ____________________________ 35
<br />a. NED cost alloca.tlon 'table for Plan D
<br />for NED compODente: -
<br />
<br />N~D componentll
<br />FC Roore- Power
<br />otlou
<br />
<br />Total
<br />
<br />1. Benefits_noon.u_n_ $60 $20 $30 $100
<br />2. Alt{'rnat!ve NED
<br />costs_...n___n____n_ $80 "" ,.,"" ,..
<br />3. Benefll.9llmlte(L_n. $30 $20 '''' $76
<br />4. 8epw-o.ble NED
<br />costsnn._.____n__n_ 110 $5 $~ $311
<br />6. RemRlnJng benafltsn $20 $10 $5 $40
<br />PercEUlt ~tributlon..._ '" 38 12 100
<br />6. Remaining Joint "$18 $18 $' ".
<br />NEDcosts_n________
<br />7. Total allocated NED
<br />costsn.n.__._._______ $" $18 '" 170
<br />
<br />Case 4--Tbe' plan la unjuat.lfIed. In terma
<br />of the national economic development ob-
<br />jective. and no alternative fonnul&Uon can
<br />be developed that 18 jUBtlfl.ed In terms of
<br />this objective but the plan Is recommended
<br />In view of net contributions to another
<br />obJeCtlve.
<br />A. pro/iCt Data:
<br />
<br />NED objective:
<br />Beneficial e1!ecta:
<br />Irrigation _h____
<br />Recreation ______
<br />Power __________
<br />
<br />RecommendeeJ
<br />Plan E
<br />
<br />.60
<br />20
<br />ao
<br />
<br />Total _________
<br />Adverse efl'ects:
<br />Project coDJJt.roc-
<br />tlon and
<br />OM&R _______
<br />Net beneflcleJ e1~
<br />tecta ___________
<br />EQ obJective:
<br />Beneficla.l and ad-
<br />verse effe<:ts.
<br />
<br />100
<br />
<br />130
<br />
<br />-30
<br />
<br />1. 3,000 acres fla.t
<br />water.
<br />2. Create 60,000
<br />acres green apace. .
<br />a. Inundate 10
<br />miles free flowing
<br />streaDl.
<br />4. Destroy 50,000
<br />a.cree at desert.
<br />
<br />easts. In this case It L!lllBSumed the envIronmental Quality
<br />benefll.9 associated witb meetllll water Qunllty BtllJld-
<br />8I'd3 over 100 'mllel!l ot stream 18 worth at. J~ $10
<br />NED costs.
<br />'Beoo1lL!l to RD ob\ectln Incldent.o.l Lo Plan D, thus
<br />no NED costs Lohe al ocll.ted to tbis objective,
<br />
|