2012-02-06_REVISION - C1981022

• Permit No: C1981022
• IBM Index Class Name: Revision
• Doc Date: 2/6/2012
• Doc Name: AVS Violation Check
• From: Alysha Hernandez
• To: Brock Bowles
• Type & Sequence: MR98
• Email Name: BFB
• Email Name: SLB
• Email Name: MR1
• Media Type: D
• Archive: No

Evaluation Report
Entity Evaluation
Entity Number
Entity Name
Date Of Narrative
Requestor
Page 1 of 2
Oxbow Mining Inc
2/1/2012 1:32:51 PM
Alysha.Hernandez
CAUTION: The Applicant/Violator System (AVS) is an informational database. Permit eligibility
determinations are made by the regulatory authority with jurisdiction over the permit application not
by the AVS. Results which display outstanding violations may not include critical information about
settlements or other conditions that affect permit eligibility. Consult the AVS Office at 800 -643-
9748 for verification of information prior to making decisions on these results.
2 Violations Found.
1: Bond Forfeiture 0035700 WV Permit:UO35700 Outstanding 12/2/1985
Violator 1: 077747 Glory Coal Co
2: Bond Forfeiture 11 0 7 4 4 011 W V Permit:U074400 Outstanding 12/2/1985
Violator 1: 077747 Glory Coal Co
Evaluation OFT
Entities: 30
153997 Oxbow Carbon & Minerals Holdings Inc - ()
- -- 093101 William I Koch - (Chief Executive Officer)
- -- 093101 William I Koch - (Director)
- -- 093101 William I Koch - (Owner)
- -- 093101 William I Koch - (President)
- -- 093105 Zachary K Shipley - (Director)
- -- 093105 Zachary K Shipley - (Treasurer)
- -- 093107 Richard P Callahan - (Director)
- -- 093107 Richard P Callahan - (Secretary)
- -- 144987 Joan E Granlund - (Owner)
- -- 155064 David W Clark - (Assistant Secretary)
- -- 248410 Oxbow Carbon LLC - (Subsidiary Company)
- - - - -- 093101 William I Koch - (Chief Executive Officer)
- - - - -- 093101 William I Koch - (Director)
- - - - -- 093101 William I Koch - (President)
- - - - -- 093105 Zachary K Shipley - (Corporate Officer)
- - - - -- 093105 Zachary K Shipley - (Director)
- - - - -- 093107 Richard P Callahan - (Director)
- - - - -- 093107 Richard P Callahan - (General Counsel)
- - - - -- 093107 Richard P Callahan - (Secretary)
- - - - -- 106338 Thomas W Ganges Jr - (Director)
- - - - -- 128003 Lawrence H Black- (Executive Vice President)
- - - - -- 153698 Steven E Fried - (Executive Vice President)
- - - - -- 155064 David W Clark - (Assistant Secretary )
- - - - -- 158132 David B Nestler - (Executive Vice President)
- - - - -- 158134 Ben Klein - (Treasurer)
- - - - -- 158139 Eric P Johnson - (Executive Vice President)
- - - - -- 248411 Barry Volpert - (Director)
- - - - -- 248412 Robert J Hurst - (Director)
- - - - -- 251598 Oxbow US Coal LLC - (Subsidiary Company)
--- - - - - -- 091993 James T Cooper - (Manager)
--- - - - - -- 091993 James T Cooper - (President)
--- - - - - -- 151178 Oxbow Mining Llc - (Subsidiary Company)
------ - - - - -- 091993 James T Cooper - (Manager)
------ - - - - -- 091993 James T Cooper - (President)
------ - - - - -- 141838 Joseph Michael Smith - (Assistant Secretary )
------ - - - - -- 144986 Oxbow Mining Inc - (Subsidiary Company)
------ - - - - -- 154002 Randy Litwiller - (Manager)
------ - - - - -- 155064 David W Clark - (Secretary)
------ - - - - -- 156172 M W Ludlow - (Executive Vice President)
------ - - - - -- 158133 John M Barnhart - (Vice President)
------ - - - - -- 158134 Ben Klein - (Treasurer)
------ - - - - -- 158147 Susan Borland - (Controller)
------ - - - - -- 158147 Susan Borland - (Vice President)
https:Hayss.osmre.gov /secure /evalreport.aspx ?i =12827 2/6/2012