|
0 FAX N0. -7 873-1742 Jun_ 1a 2009 0 aPM P6
<br />Palle 4 czf'
<br />/-L vvitric_.ss c)ri behalf of plra.i.n.ti.ff testi tied tlz.at the compa.lay OWIZiI7.?T t11e .LY,I,pT'eSS tLin11e1, which was
<br />a.bc-)lxt 3,000 feet in lel-lgth, charged twenty-five cents per car for waste. 1ln4Dthcr witness for pl-a-inti ll-
<br />stated that th.e chaLrge n-i:Lcl . by the 1VcwlzoLase tLLiznel, wllicll was sonlctlling like. eight thottsaxicl feet in
<br />erligth, waA,-; c>nz .f'czrty-five to forty-six cents per ton for waste. It also a.ppe.-Lrs frozxl th.e evicienc;e tliztt the
<br />Sig Five tursizcl 1•zad a scht°dLlle for. tite traarzsportatiori of waste up to the lcngtlz of 7,55-00 feet, bc.ct: the
<br />;checlLal+e pe:.r tczil is not staxed.. Fr1.ch
<br />..__._.............. Pages 547 ............... .... .,. ... ... ....... .. <..»......><.. .,»...».»... ?_ ..,
<br />z-Ft-hene tLinnels waas what rnig,ht be ter. n.eci "cc>n?lzierc iaal tuz-incJS," and was cC3rlstrLlctCd by tllc cc zM-Par-ly
<br />:Pvvilirxg of operatirig it For the plxrpc>se c:),i' trarls-porting ore and waste fi'oni tlzc xtrrz.ftxa lim.14 properties which
<br />lc respective tun-u:ls intersected. FacJ? <W tl-iosc companies had constructed its tunnel., OwzaeLl the cars
<br />and tracks, axici fu.rzzisJa.ea the rnc',tivc power, rind. U-S to c>ne c>I'tlie Cc?lr?pranie a, at
<br />leaar;t, lc>a3clc?d t11C cars, a•zz?
<br />1-1 each case: transported the J.oaded t'ftrn tc3 the: rn.outlz of tlzc tul'1[le1, dumped th.eY-M, at.n.d retLirlleci tlLelzz
<br />:?x?zl>ty icy il-le •i>laC.C where they were l.c?atci'ecl_ Thc--Sc Facts furnisli no basis from which to G?i7.apu.-te wlza t
<br />3c:fe_riclarnt should pay per toat.- TT= had c:c>1ZstrLlctccl t11c, tunnel at his own expense, laid the trrl-c J. therein,
<br />C>aadecl, :zzc7v4--6 acid dLlinpcd t.hc cars. Plaiiviti UV waL:a s1t 1-11La expeizse 'whate'ver i1.1 army respect. -1'hc Clista..ct.cc
<br />:he cars were traa•lspc>.rted threzLtgh the I±:lida was r1bCiL).t Er-itlrteen le.uncirecl (eat, as ce-l'1-riparc-cl with the three:
<br />;h.vLlsat?.t3 feet haul czf tlzc L.rnpress tunnel, ei.gbt thC>-usand feet, the length of tkie '1Vcwlzouse tUx i el, a%, I
<br />acvcnty-five hundred feet, the length of the L3ig Hive tU.n.27C-1- C?lefzrly, Lander these flic.As, wlzat.t sLlriz per tot
<br />-3.1aint.i f'f' wnulcl 1->c entitled to recover fl"ox the usr?- czfthe Lllcla turiziel, her irntcrest beizig but a.zz ux-i.dividccl
<br />_-i,n.e-b.tilf, c.c-oiild. 11e1t ize cczmputed, E-Aind .zriy attex?zl>t tc.> dc> sc> wc•>Llld rest orl rnere. GorljEctvtro.
<br />It is evident. that if relinble- data was furnished. which wc>LLI.d ?:erve a3:; ti lzaisis LLPLyn wliicli to eompu.te
<br />.what plaintiff would be eraitlecl tC> receive per ton, tElkirl. zx?tc> c;c:>1lsicleration the lc rhatfi of the Llid.a.
<br />-urizzel, as 4t712117cirCt.? with the. length C>f. tl-le 1zaLd in tlic other tunnels merlticart.ed, th.e cc.>,t c>t` c c>lzstrtaction.
<br />:and coperatic om, and that defezt.datnt fur'-"Shed the cars a.zzci track, and mczved. thorn without azzy ex.pensc
<br />o/.hctever. to the plr i-itilY, that the a.rnoru Zt sh-e would be entitled to ,receive per tcrrl wc7LLlC1 17c very
<br />ziflter.iull_v red-uce:d '1'rorn that ch.argecl Y>y the CJt7t22II1C t'clc].1
<br />.-....,,...,.,. ..................... ........................... ..,,..,...,..,.,..,..,.,......... .........,.,....,.. _._,... ,.. F"ajoe 548 -.-....................... ......... .....
<br /> -..... ..... -,.._........,.............................,................................ ........ .......
<br />...,.....,...,..
<br />:Lrn.ltel.: tc] which we laave referred.
<br />It also appears that -for the sprtce c7 f between two artci l:l?ree rricintl-is plaintifr- Litilizcd for her berzef i t
<br />alone 324 feet o.[` t13c-, tut-1r1c1 for the trzan,pc7rtation of ore or waste :f:rt11.t-1 the prc7l?c:rtics in which slze wars
<br />:yzterested. She should cer-tuinly account to the cierl.'ex?da3x?t -661- the value of this LxSe, fc11 1.11s interost tllereir.
<br />C•31-1 the authority c>:[` H?nr?ess?y v 1Yvcrg, 1 6 L.olo. 460, it is cczntendcd by counsel for appellant that t1.r
<br />zcticzle for. vise =1nd cnccftlpatinn c€anzzot be xxut:irktaixzecl except it uppear!tz the re.-latiolz of la,rndlord. rsncl totiant
<br />3x•istecl betweern tla.e parties. They also cantezzd tl•taat iri the absence ct,f. a.:,ta-liLLte err agrcctnezi.t tc-) tht,
<br />zozitrrlry, a teriant in c-ctxln¦tiYr>rt, while rxerely in possessi.L>n c>('thc coYr?mc>xi pr.c>p&rty, 1'1cit exeltadi.z•1g lzis
<br />2?0-tciza.nt, nc?r denying him equal crnjoytrsextt, canjac3t be charged lzy the latter for rise ;mvici czcc-upatic n.- Fez
<br />these reasons it is c:czlztc:ndcd the ractiozz at bFa.r c"nnot be zzzailztaainecl. We do tzot d.eexn it -nocessa.ry to
<br />zji:,cLass thcsc gLiestic.>n y. Tlzc law cif' the: case, a.s cleclr-Lrcci when. tb.e C 4iLiSC: was here befl.-)rre, is to the c ['! E c
<br />that deflendalzt Lmust .rccc>rnpe:rzsc nlal:i.n.t.i rr rat- the use cat` .aor -interest in the turm.ol fcz•r trmispc>rtitig rc>ek .
<br />Vec7•r71 an outside prc,>perty. 'Tlze deterizlinatioiz c>f' this qucstic>tl. watt essc.rltia.l tt7 a deci.si-orL Lzf the cat :c, as
<br />lhext. presex-2-ted. Qvicstkivi -; of law *befc.wi-c U-10, coL1.J7t fclr Cleeision and by the: ct),urt decided as essential tc> rct
<br />final jLtdgrn.eizt, arc-- conc_1L?sivc.ly arlci lillaally adjucUC:ate:d, a.nd carxrxc>t be charn.ge.d LLlzcstz a subsegLxent
<br />Q.Ppeat I .
<br />httn://66. 161 . ].4 1 . 1 76/e i-1>.i.1z/texts/web/casclaw/ -9oMc13VI{CTwT3rne.l;jza.erlZRwwwxi ql_ r... 31221-20C
|