PERMFILE110830

• Permit No: C1980007
• IBM Index Class Name: Revision
• Doc Date: 6/13/2005
• Doc Name: Exhibit 4 Sources of Legal Right to Enter
• Type & Sequence: PR10
• Media Type: D
• Archive: No

West Elk Mine
• 2,769.67 acres, Gunnison County, Colorado.
Tract 2: T. 13 S., R 90 W., 6`" P.M.
Modification sec. 25, 35 and 36 Beginning at the northwest corner of said sec. 35;
Thence S 89 45' E, 2308.02 feet along the north line to the north % comer of said sec.
35;
Thence S 89 51' E, 755.52 feel along the north line of said sec. 35 to the Tme Point of
Beginning;
Thence S 89 51' E, 1948.49 feet to the northeast comer of said sec. 35:
Thence N 1 34' E, 554.17 feet to the west line of said sec. 25;
Thence S 77 34' 46" E, 537.12 feet;
Thence S 12 25' 34" W, 1767,64 feet;
Thence S 77 34' 26" E, 117.32 feet;
Thence S 12 25' 34" W, 1370.14 feet
Thence S 77 34' 26" E, 310.65 feet;
Thence S 12 25' 34" W, 379.75 feet;
Thence N 77 34' 26" W, 2272.95 feet;
Thence N 1 33' E, 2605.75 feet to the Tme Point of Beginning
149.48 acres, Gunnison County, Colorado
Containing 2,919.16 acres, more or less
• 22. Federal Coal Lease COC 67011, September 1, 2004, by the United States of America as lessor and Ark
Land Company, as lessee, embracing the following described lands in Gunnison County, Colorado:
T. 13S., R. 90 W., 6`s P.M.
sec. 12, lots 8 to 1Q inclusive;
sec. 13, lots 2 to 7, inclusive, and
lots 10 to 15, inclusive,
sec. 24, lots 4 and 5.
690 acres, Gunnison County, Colorado.
Containing 690.95 acres mare or less.

EXHIBIT 4 PG. 11 November, 2004 PRI G