Laserfiche WebLink
<br />/~17T=R: ~Jll~ <br />r7,tve AI:.::. <br />I1 jir~ 1 ~ <br />(b) Yoter,lia} IJamagc <br />~t:ccrdir,'~ t~ ti1: Civil Fc:~slTy Pq};;;~~, Scc::ar, ul. i.~i.. "If-i:c • ~~~lstor .an :;how <br />1hr01i~!'i in-itCC311^. ,;I IT'.hl:iii Ua!a, al::Jul Cit~l:Cr~? iln(i Str 2uin l`"~~ d]ta; bi JiTll';11tt7rlnL <br />rCSUI:S, ~!':., teal 1C(4t11 CO'1 ~It1011S l0 the rC~C:~ ~B~ water 35 2 fCiL'.t Ot tnc (h5~.:rargJ <br />w~ ul(1 F.ul C [CSlll:.d ill'.!t::C tlr 730 !:1.^.13gC :C ?.'.C OCI;CLSCIdl S13t:5. tF'L' i;ptCrl:ill dII1P.iiSC <br />pOf;'On ^_[ thl' rCl)alt)' F7,1}' !7C PCdt1CCd 1)v u: C~.l:i.11 uu"$ ilft}' ,!e"I:CIli.'• AC.:GCaILlb tf7 the <br />A.rs.'S CSF:1 ,•lcaalty :+-`.SCSStriGnl, 8;~1 rrUaln:7 Si7C D:YI51C111 -x.1~'! (he JC:CC:iIIIo }.~:Cl <br />Risk :1SSCSS7n;;:lt (TR•i.L, ?.ppeZdx D, ~:~rcE; i979; au:(i d raWbcsc with •xatcr Scslity <br />darn from [:~~-~. ii1d4E'xe:v Gtc }7rimary !IIrOC:S,::iOn (C:Le:i:..'~Jn ~}' i17C ~':8:,: 171 ;li;teI- <br />'.ninlne' i'~t.1::5 for the Ci~~i} pei;?.itv a55CS5t;;l:ai. 'I'f~iS inMhn5t:J6 !i1115 tt7 ml;ludC am' <br />l•ion7oni*.orir,g jztP, direct tlo•.v data vr'c:u21 l:%ilucnt dtSra. T:;e :14t faits iv 7ne11~ it:.any <br />watcrGua}i!: ~.IwtF.:10N';tsSroam ofl:irl's.'ce en (u.s.. t; 917&i.,[n H;.n ,. , <br />c v le ci7 nesdertt~, tt <br />alsc+ Mils .o cur7sit~er :hope recent daW :root :n•strcam salt:pi:^« cries on $4!'s prOpC:lV <br />tf•'~'., ZS•<, iZcJ-i rr1, C[L. ~. 1'IP. wily, tril; .SI: CC^.il l ~:.CYt: It7sk :~i: ~::+SltlCnr I=1tC~ Ul.'Gn fi7T 15 <br />to consider the full range of gollutancs prscrt in the Wtst Pit, which are ~auitd ir. <br />U•ihutrrv ~,Yate:a to the Ri:o Sc(:o. <br />Itt conclusion, Hi'vl providcd a lim7led surrtrar} of ds.a 17y wl:ic the state ;?cteZniaed l+ae <br />intoner This selected inforrnalion fails to 17rovid: a reasonauie Sasis open which the <br />start can mrke el de:enninalion. eased on t17e psuciry of (}a:~ :onsidcrcd; a^d :hc I,.ck of <br />"real" information sulTpa~ing the >'ssc.^.ion She the_e has beer. (or will L•~j }irtle or no <br />darnagc tc ben~ficiai uses, ?he seltlenlcrt arbittwrity grants l3.`.' ilrpruper penzlty <br />rcductions- <br />Section I11, i.A., of the Civil Yenalry ?olicy state Illat when ar. unpetrlitted dischal~gc <br />occurs thl: penalty shGUIJ tiVASidcr "~ite•spccilic flow sa:nplin~." Itio such data is <br />providcd. "ln t11C nbscnca of such data the pnn:.i:y will be based on ... snd auy cy'ewit- <br />ncss or st~cr-the-ft7ct asscssmtnt of the impact the dis;,hargc had on the receiving <br />wattrs.' CCCD has docuutcntcd extensive staining and aig1~11'omation is and around <br />the m7pc.':.lit~-d steps. CCCD slaCalco has o}TSCrvcd mineral bogs downsr:cam of the <br />unpemTiited discllacgcs. CCCD ca17 else delnoltstrate in-S[r::,m srzndsrd violations at th(: <br />headga:c ,°or the Shalom ianch tivatr. tight dcw:utrcam on the bite ScCO, which CUFItE <br />fnils to cansidrr in the settlement. <br />~.IfD1.a0h~:. cq:~ ~..h,i vc. ~...,.s, <br />