Laserfiche WebLink
lass in the autaunt of X48,000.00. ~ <br />Ventiiatiop Shad: As pact oftlse discussions sad of the Agreements in May/7une <br />1488 be~.weeu Tatum and Wyoming Fuel, Wyoming Fuel coo: tr-~: `c' - -: -:*i!~aT ~!~a~ ^n <br />• ".-•=`~" y'''-~' =~mediate coz~sh-uetiou of tl±a Gh~ft ws~ rectaired for safety <br />pxiajiex:y ut~*fiei: ~J ; --._.;:..:. ..,-- .... <br />reasons. The shaft effectively deprived Tatum of the use and benefit of approximatety four <br />acres of his laud. The fair market value of this four acres at the :is w <""••~ ~:.:.s~~r.-~ af+~P <br />veutilariaa snag 'w=an ;~e,u~;u y3 ~,,.:. ;,rz+e. The evidence present,°~ st +~;ati .i;~l r?+?ti ~~± ~3.1ie}, the <br />existel]ce ai &'rrf;,.a..:b :. ».-.. ':ry'e1l GII the properly. Tatum should be compepsated`for tiitB loss <br />of this acreage. The damage and lass to Tatum fox this de4: i'. ~' ;; nr ~ ~^. - _. <br />ovhich can be awarded herein ~ limited to S15,o00.00, ~: ,. a~ disclese~ ±r<; la;rti!~:' <br />AQlended DiscIOSUCe St3teIIleat <br /><~~i'" <br />_ at.iomev i'ees: a~;::::r ~:.'rs' claims or defenses in this case appear t0 the C^urt to be <br />groun2lcss, ,~i:~oi~:t:s ar', ~}:~c+us. The trial of this case was dit:ficuh far all par6~s and the <br />Court because of the persona! anud emotional involvement of the nlxi.:,^:iy;, r*es-~Tmrg L~~ie <br />OWrI GSSe, an(t zne delatlCtafltS' ~ i~4::b.i~:::d w 3~~awladge li.:bili ~ _.~J' n~f+l.P vas+.,~ <br />Nert~ 1~Y nos suvvMU ~y „ YFcpa -dv;-~~P ^f*!~e evidence an entitlement to attorney fees. <br />'~~ _,. <br />r'~]NCLUSIONS OF LA.W <br />1. The 3une 1,1998 Agreement . Tatum and BRI is enforceable accord~g `. z» <br />V:t~vs. Ocrmers of water rigixts are its to ~,il or rx~nge their rights to the use of water. <br />Here, the parries sirr-piy ~~ ' `-,-' "~ ~' ~ "=,c,=~'~ 'sue the others' water and, recognizing the <br />. effect of priorities, agreed on~ow to handle tl:c sitc:etion when the exchange could not be <br />accomplished becaxrse of shortfalls. <br />2. Owners of wafer rights can egrh~ ono the use of each others' water sub'ect to the <br />fonmaIities req'uixed try law which may iu..lude adjudication of the rights in wat~ court <br />3. 'The owsrer of coal mineral tights is liable far damages caused to properly b~ ~''c <br />. ,.. <br />op.:..atian o: their undergra'c~nu wal rni'ming oprratioras. SuY"i'aCe owners are entitli~; w xs:~: ~~.: <br />.,.., ... <br />;- damages caused to then nuraxw c;. ,.-~~°,.~ ....,,.~ ....:::::;.inn subsidence. Nsre, ground <br />' subsidence by the undcrg±rnn~ r~.nsl minixeg overatio:~ wed gg,.~,ng;.ai movement and <br />.: ,.. damage to plaintiffs,' residence. <br />I <br />!'' j <br />.7AN-Z7-~Q0_ FR.7 ?~:1'AM I0: pgrr.c <br />LI 39bd Wfiltll WIP 69t09b86tL 5t~9t 000Z/Z0/b0 <br />. _ .,., <br />._,....:. _.ra~ <br />