GENERAL41988 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

In the last page of the 1953 Receiver's Deed to San Miguel County under the heading "OTHER PROPERTY: "it states the following: "Any and all other real estate and interests in real estate in San Miguel County, Colorado, owned by or standing in the name of the Rio Grande Southern Railroad Company, except rrghts of way conveyed to the Department of Highways, State of Colorado, under deed dated on or about February 17, 1953". This is an example of a "catch all" clause in a deed. They are referring to real property in fee simple that the RGSRR owned after it abandoned the railroad's rights of way and easements that may have been missed in this deed. It is not meant to convey all the land that was ever considered a right of way or easement for the RGSRR in San Miguel County, Colorado. The RGSRR's Receiver knew that it could not convey real property that it d.id not own. Per Federal Statute rights of way and easement acquired by permit by the US Govermnent across public lands revests to the US Government upon abandonment of right of way and easement. They could not convert a permit to a fee simple title. In summary, if San Miguel County did not acquire a fee simple interest in any abandoned RGSRR railroad and easement in Section 32 of Township 42 North, Range 9 West in the said 1953 Receiver's Deed, how did it feel it could clear the title to the ownership of the above described mining claims and real property it was alleged to convey in the subject Quit Claim Deed from San Miguel County to PDI. The opinion of this report is that San Miguel County never had the ownership of the said abandoned rights of way and easements that cross the above described mining claims and real property in the subject Quit Claim Deed from SMC to PDI, is further evidenced by the Pipe Line Easement deed dated June 8, 1956 from Monarch Mines, Inc., a corporation of the State of Colorado to the Western Colorado Power Company, a corporation of the State of Colorado that conveyed a right of way and easement for the pipeline in the same abandoned RGSRR railroad right of way and easement as it crossed the same mining claims described in the subject Quit Claim Deed from San Miguel County to PDI. The Westem Colorado Power Company, which did their due diligence on the ownership of the abandoned railroad right of cvay, and had access to the same 1953 Receiver's Deed to San Miguel County, determined that the ownership of the abandoned right of way and easement as it crossed the lands described in the subject Quit Claim Deed from San Miguel County to PDI, was vested in The Western Colorado Power Company not San Miguel County. One may be able to make the case that the abandoned right of way that was originally acquired by a permit on US Government land would eventually revert to the private property owners of record. A court action quieting the title to the subject area is the correct way to establish the ownership of the lands described as that portion of the abandoned Rio Grande Southern Railroad Right of Way as described in the subject Quit Claim Deed from SMC to PDI. Having SMC grant a quit claim deed on such a thin claim of title does not help remove a cloud on the title but create more questions as to the true ownership of that portion of the abandoned Rio Grande Southern Railroad Right of Way as de>cribed in the subject Quit Claim Deed from SMC to PDI. 4