GENERAL33643 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

decisions" where hazardous or toxic substances threatened to contaminate surrounding properties and water supplies, any potentially hazardous conditions at the Quarry are contained within the site. In subsequent decisions examining Midlantic, courts focused primarily on whether there was a serious health risk from the presence of toxic and hazardous substances that presented an inevitable and imminent harm to the public. In this case, Colorado failed to provide credible evidence that similar risks exist at the Quarry. Colorado's remaining concern is the possibility that trespassers maybe harmed by entering the Quarry site. Where the hazards were merely speculative or indeterminate, prior courts did not find that the hazards or dangers were so imminent as to preclude abandonment under Midlantic. See Smith-Douglass, 856 F.2d. at 12; Anthony Ferrante 6c Sons, 119 B.R. at 49. The conditions at the Quarry do not present a risk or threat of inevitable harm or unavoidable danger to the public. The Quarry only presents a danger to someone who unlawfully trespasses onto the site and fails to take adequate notice of an obvious and potentially dangerous condition. The Quarry site is conspicuous and entirely avoidable. The chance that someone might be injured at the site in the foreseeable future is merely conjecture. See, In Re Smith•Douglars, 856 F.2d. 12 (4th Cv. 1988)(coutt approves abandonment o[ fenilizer plant that had released hazardous contaminants into surrounding water supply where there was no threat of immediate harm); /n Re Anrhorry Ferrante & Sons, Inc, 119 B.R, 45 (D.NJ. 1990)(court approves abandonment of~ntaminated publicwatersupplysystem absent showing of immediateaad identifiable harm); In Re Oklahoma Refining Co., 63 B.R. 562 (Bankr. W.D. Okla. 1986)(eourt approval abandonment of oil refinery that had dumped hazardous oil byproducu into open pits that were leaching into the surrounding underground water supply but the site did not present immediate and menacing harm); In Re Doyle Camber, Inc., 137 B.R 197 (Bankr. W.D. Va. 1992)(court approved abandottment of sawmill and wood vestment facility site containing hazardous wastes [hat did not present immediate thtcat to public health and safety).