Laserfiche WebLink
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT JUSTIFICATION <br />NOV C-93-025 <br />Assessment Conference Summary <br />Nov C-93-025 was issued by Susan Morrison of the Division for <br />"[F]ailure to include a description and detailed design for each <br />existing structure, for which there are specific design criteria or <br />performance standards, proposed to be used in connection with or to <br />facilitate the surface coal mining and reclamation operations". <br />The NOV referenced various berms, ditches, and culverts within <br />portions of the Edna Mine permit area for which specific designs or <br />descriptions were required, but had not been submitted. <br />For several of the structures, the Operator representatives <br />conceded that oversights occurred and the required designs had not <br />been provided. However, they indicated that designs for "Goat <br />Trail" access road culverts had been provided. Subsequent review <br />of Exhibit 3.5-1 (Sheet 2 of 2) and Table 3.5-3 has confirmed this <br />and the NOV will need to be modified. The Operator also argued <br />that the berm on the east side of the shop warehouse pad was an <br />MSHA required safety berm not required for drainage or materials <br />containment purposes, and the Division indicated that this would be <br />researched and the NOV modified if appropriate. The Operator <br />contended that the typical road ditch designs in the permit applied <br />to the "Goat Trail" access road as well as haul roads, but conceded <br />that this was not specified in the permit. <br />Fact of Violation <br />The Operator representatives conceded that required designs for <br />certain structures had not been provided. I find that a violation <br />did occur. <br />Civil Penalty Assessment <br />Proposed Penalty Assessment <br />History $ 0.00 <br />Seriousness 500.00 <br />Fault 250.00 <br />Good Faith 0.00 <br />Total $750.00 <br />History <br />The History component was not disputed. <br />Seriousness <br />The cited deficiencies were apparently permitting oversights. <br />