Laserfiche WebLink
July 21, 1995 <br />Page 3 <br />which had not been previously stripped of topsoil. While the <br />area is small, topsoil contamination is considered a serious <br />matter. Based upon observations during the inspection on July <br />12, 1995, it appears that the violation was properly issued. <br />Penalty <br />It appears that MCC disagrees with the Division regarding the <br />facts of the violation, which is most appropriately handled <br />during the assessment conference. The Assessment Officer <br />bases the amount of the penalty on the information available <br />at the time of his or her review. Rule 5.04.3(1) allows the <br />operator to submit, within 15 days of service of a notice of <br />violation, written information about the violation to the <br />Division. The Assessment Officer is required to consider this <br />information in determining the facts surrounding the violation <br />and the amount of the civil penalty. This information was not <br />received until June 28, 1995, and we must notify the operator <br />of the amount of the proposed civil penalty within 30 days of <br />service of a notice of violation. The $2,250.00 is a proposed <br />penalty. It does not become final until the penalty is fixed <br />which would occur if an operator does not request an <br />assessment conference or following an assessment conference if <br />one is held at the request of the operator. During the <br />assessment conference MCC is granted an opportunity to discuss <br />the facts of the violation. In addition, I would urge you to <br />discuss the proposed civil penalty. I do have some concern <br />about the way the proposed penalty was calculated. If a final <br />penalty is assessed I assure you I will review the assessment <br />before it is forwarded to you. <br />Please feel free to call with any questions. <br />Sincerely, <br />Michael B. ong <br />Division Dire <br />cc: Susan McCannon <br />David Berry <br />Tony Waldron <br />Christine Johnston <br />m:\coal\cej\NOV016 <br />