APPCOR10867 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

(3) In response to our original adequacy comments, the consultant amended pages 39.3 thcough 34.7 of Appendix 4.5-1 to present a more- comprehensive discussion of slope stability and subsidence relationships on Coal Ridge. The amended application observes that moderate slumping and landsliding is limited to areas "outside and below the anticipated areas of surface subsidence effects." (page 39.5) with the exception of one questionable portion of the northeastern face of Horse Mountain, the Division concurs with that opinion. There appears, however, to be extensive geomorphic evidence of ancient slope movements througout large portions of the slopes on the northeast face of Coal Ridge. On pages 41.1 and 41.2 of the amended Appendix 4.5-1, the consultantdescribes a proposed visual monitoring program which will specifically observe slope characteristics considered indicative of slope movement, such as "...surface cracking, movement of large rock blocks and the development of bulging ground near the base of the slope." the amended application's Appendix 4.5-1 also presents a detailed proposed program for mitigation of slope stability problems. Simplistically, in areas where no danger is presented to structures, mine personnel or the public, the applicant proposes to restrict access and visually observe manifested slope instability phenomena. In any areas where a hazard exists to structures, mine personnel or the public, the operator will also, "...as necessary and appropriate, provide slope stabilization techniques". As amended, however, vagueness exists concerning the role of the Division in the decision of whether or not a hazard to structures, mine personnel or the public exists. To avoid possible future disagreement, our eventual findings will impose a stipulation which clearly states that the Division shall review and concur with any decision of whether a hazard is represented by any specific slope movement event and whether a slope stabilizationprogram should be developed and implemented, (4) It will be important to clearly present the results of the visual and survey monitoring programs at the Coal Ridge No 1 Mine. The amended application presents no detail regarding the formate of the semi-annual subsidence monitoring reports. In the interest of facilitating complete and efficient presentation of the accumulated subsidence monitoring data, our eventual findings will include a stipulation requiring the submission of a proposed subsidence report format within six months following issuance of the permit." SKM Response: