Laserfiche WebLink
145 <br /> 1 water, but I was told that they did, in fact, add 1 report. <br /> 2 water to the sinkhole at the north end of the !, 2 MR. JUSTUS: Yeah. <br /> 3 Fontanari Ditch. 3 A. Are we talking page 3 of the -- <br /> 4 Q. Of the Fontanari trench? 4 Q. (BY MR. BECKMH) Figure 3. <br /> 5 A. Yes. 5 A. Figure 3. Oh, yes. That is the rock <br /> 6 Q. Now, in the lower left-hand corner of 6 pile, not the air shaft. That is the rock pile <br /> 7 this particular exhibit, is there a description that 7 pile. This — this picture corresponds to the red <br /> 8 says a round circle in red is a sinkhole surface 8 dot southeast of the vent shaft on the air photo on <br /> 9 expression? 9 the left hand of this screen. <br /> 10 A. Yes. 10 Q. So you're testifying that this <br /> 11 Q. So in other words, if I read this 11 photograph is not the air shaft that is referenced <br /> 12 correctly, there were three, possibly four sinkholes 12 in any of the reports? <br /> 13 in this tract in April of 2016 that your people 13 A. This picture? <br /> 14 observed? 14 Q. Correct. <br /> 15 A. Well, there were three holes within 15 A. To the best of my knowledge, that is <br /> 16 the ditch. 16 correct. <br /> 17 Q. Okay. One was where it turns -- 17 MR. BECMITH: Mr. Stark, would you <br /> 18 A. Correct. 18 go to page 6 of this exhibit for me, please? <br /> 19 Q. -- to the west? 19 Q. (BY MR. BECKRITH) Is this the same <br /> 20 A. Uh-huh. 20 location on Exhibit B, page 6 that is illustrated in <br /> 21 Q. And were two more also in that san�e 21 Figure 3 of Exhibit A-29? <br /> 22 area? 22 A. I'm not sure. <br /> 23 A. Yes. 23 Q. Would you go, please, to Exhibit 31, <br /> 24 Q. And was a third one to the southeast 24 which is -- should be the August 2016 Fugro report? <br /> 25 location of the yellow circle? 25 Do you have it, sir? <br /> 145 147 <br /> 1 A. Are you referring to the one where -- 1 A. Yes. <br /> 2 below where it says "ERT anomaly boundary"? 2 Q. And do you have it in front of you? <br /> 3 Q. No. I'm referring to a circle in 3 A. Yes. <br /> 4 yellow where it -- 4 Q. Is that the same photograph that <br /> 5 A. Oh, the yellow. 5 appears in Exhibit A-29 as Figure 3? <br /> 6 Q. -- says "vent shaft." 6 A. Yes. <br /> 7 A. Okay. Yes. That one there, yes. 7 Q. The one you previously examined? <br /> 8 Q. Okay. So that we have this oriented 8 A. Correct. <br /> 9 correctly, north is at the top of this picture on 9 Q. And is that the same location as the <br /> 10 the left? 10 staff as indicated to this Board is the docLmnted <br /> 11 A. Yes. So you're referring to the red 11 vent shaft location? <br /> 12 circle southeast of there? 12 A. I don't have an answer to that <br /> 13 Q. Yes. 13 question. Looking at the pictures, they don't look <br /> 14 A. That is what has been identified, to 14 the same. <br /> 15 the best of my knowledge, as the rock pile. 115 Q. Mr. Berry. <br /> 16 Q. Okay. And is that different from the 16 A. Yes, sir. <br /> 17 air ventilation shaft? 117 Q. In April of -- so that I understand <br /> 18 A. Yes. 18 it correctly, you went out in roughly June of 2014. <br /> 19 Q. Would you examine, please, the Fugro 19 Shortly after the incident occurred with the water, <br /> 20 report fran April of 2016 and tell me whether there 20 you investigated the portal — the seal of the <br /> 21 is a figure in the photograph taken -- I believe 21 portal in determining whether or not there were any <br /> 22 it's Figure 3 — that shows the rock -- that shows 22 problems and whether or not there was a public <br /> 23 the air ventilation shaft? 23 safety issue. Am I correct? <br /> 24 MR. BECMITH: And, I believe, 24 A. That's correct. <br /> 25 Mr. Justus, that is adait 29. It is the Fugro 25 Q. And then you testified that you and <br /> 146 148 <br />