Laserfiche WebLink
65 <br /> 1 Q. In larger size. 1 MR. ROBERTS: You'd sustain the <br /> 2 A. But is this the map you're referring 2 objection. <br /> 3 to, before I blow it up? 13 MR. SINGLETARY: I'll sustain the <br /> 4 Q. Yes. Yes. That is page 9. 4 objection. <br /> 5 A. Okay. Yes, sir. 15 MR. ROBERTS: Yeah, sustain. <br /> 6 Q. In the lower corner by the Carey Pond 6 Q. (BY MR. BEMITH) Let me rephrase. <br /> 7 it says "Abandoned Section." 7 Underneath in that area where it says "Abandon <br /> 8 A. Yes. 8 Section," what understanding do you have of the <br /> 9 Q. What does the mean in terms of a map 9 existence or nonexistence of previously excavated <br /> 10 for a mine? 10 underground coal caverns? <br /> 11 A. According to Snowcap -- and I dial it A. It's my understanding that the area <br /> 12 inquire about this -- this is a mined-out area. 12 was mined at one point. <br /> 13 Q. That is correct. So in other words, 113 Q. Okay. And abandoned for whatever <br /> 14 "Abandoned Section" means there have been 14 reason? <br /> 15 underground workings, and they have either ccrrpleted 15 A. Yes. You'll have to get that from <br /> 16 then or they walked away from then for whatever 16 sanebody else. Sorry. <br /> 17 reason; is that correct? 17 MR. BECMTH: Okay. Thank you. <br /> 18 A. You would have to ask the specifics 18 Nothing further. <br /> 19 fran Snowcap. 19 MR. SINGLETARY: Okay. <br /> 20 Q. It is your exhibit and your map. 20 MR. MiUFLZ: Are there any other <br /> 21 A. Actually, it's your exhibit. I 21 questions for Mr. Stark before we turn it over to <br /> 22 believe it's your Exhibit 1. 22 Mr. Boulay? <br /> 23 Q. Taken from your agency. 23 MR. STUTZ: I would have some on <br /> 24 A. Right. 24 behalf of Mr. Carey. <br /> 25 MR. JUSTUS: Objection. You're 25 Mr. Stark-- <br /> 65 67 <br /> 1 asking for speculation by the witness. 1 THE COURT REPORTER: You need to <br /> 2 MR. BECMITH: No, I'm not. I'm 2 identify yourself. <br /> 3 asking for a definition of a term on a mine map -- 3 MR. STUTZ: I am very sorry. My namie <br /> 4 MR. JUSTUS: You're asking him to 4 is Greg Stutz, and I'm representing Jason Carey in <br /> 5 speculate as to the -- ! 5 this matter. <br /> 6 MR. BECKRITH: -- filed by -- 6 ESAMINATION <br /> 7 MR. SINGLETARY: One at a time. 7 BY MR. STUTZ: <br /> 8 MR. JUSTUS: --meaning inplied. 8 Q. Mr. Stark, does anything in Technical <br /> 9 MR. ROBERTS: On a procedural point, 9 Revision 69 affect any portion of the Jason Carey <br /> 10 we have an objection to a cross-examination 10 property? <br /> 11 question. Mr. Chair, it's your discretion to 11 A. No. Everything is limited to this — <br /> 12 uphold -- to sustain the objection or overrule it. 12 you know, the general four-tenths of an acre that we <br /> 13 MR. SINGLETARY: Restate the 13 saw on that reclamation map, and that's all -- <br /> 14 objection. 14 again, as long as the property line is correct, it's <br /> 15 MR. JUSTUS: Mr. Beckwith is asking 15 all on the Fontanari Tract 71 area. So it's all <br /> 16 Mr. Stark to speculate as to the meaning ascribed to 16 kind of limited to this area here (indicated). <br /> 17 a label on a map by the operator. Mr. Stark's 17 Q. Does the technical revision that's <br /> 18 testimony regarding this map did not address that. 18 under consideration here have any effect upon the <br /> 19 He did not offer any testimony regarding what 19 existing bond? <br /> 20 "Abandoned Section" meant. 20 A. It does. <br /> 21 His testimony was solely limited to 21 Q. And can you tell us what that is, <br /> 22 identifying the location of an air shaft on this 22 please? <br /> 23 map. So this cross-examination is also beyond the 23 A. It will increase the bowl by 35,000. <br /> 24 scope of direct. 24 It's 34,000 and sane change. <br /> 25 MR. SINGLETARY: I'd overrule it. 25 Q. Right. <br /> 66 68 <br />