|
<br />.
<br />
<br />c;
<br />
<br />~
<br />~
<br />f,lr
<br />~.
<br />
<br />.
<br />
<br />.--~ -
<br />
<br />1
<br />
<br />()
<br />~
<br />
<br />Supreme Court of the United States
<br />
<br />I
<br />
<br />:\1), ,-,. ('rj~'il](II.-1 h''!"iIHEI{ TI::H:\l. 1!J-l.:i.
<br />
<br />TlIl' :--:'lilll' ,,1" ('\\\,\\,(\11,,_ ('l\l\lplainill\1.
<br />
<br />1
<br />tl :ill
<br />
<br />ill Eq'lify.
<br />
<br />I'~
<br />Till' Still,' 01' 1\<111:-..;1..... Pt. ,iI.
<br />
<br />11)('('j'lllhl'r Ii. .l!I-L:'1
<br />
<br />:,\11', .111'" k,' !:lIl:un.~ dc" in'l'cd tlit' OJlillioll of t II!' (:0111'1.
<br />
<br />Thi~ ~Ili! i:-; lhl' l;]l(~"'llJr il sl'l"i\'s of liti!!illiollS IIl~t\\'p('ll ]\iLIISil:o.., 1l1.lll'I./.j'il."tl....
<br />..nll\ C"ltlrilll'J. ll)' Ill'l' l',ili:t.ell";. ('l'IlWl~illillg' tlll'il' 1'/'sIH'di\'(~ rights to tl1(' hl'l]l'livial
<br />11:-Of' lIf till' \\";1 1 f>l'S or tll(' ~\]'lalt1SilS Hi'"t'l",
<br />
<br />TIlt' l'J"er 111l~ ih ol'i~il1 ill {'('1111'.1I Cldnt'ildo, rind is a llIolllllaill tolTt'l1t fill'
<br />] ::0 mill'... tll il JloillT 11(',11' ('HltlllJ Cit," W}ICl'C it. elltl'!"::: H f(lotl1illl'(':,!inll l'IHlill~ II(';I!"
<br />/'111'1110_ 'i'hl'lll't' il tl"ll\.t.I.....('S 1111..' hi~h plilills I)f .'j[;-.;1t'I'1I Coll)\'iulfJ illlll \\"('"tl'l"l)
<br />1\;111:-.11". ]n thl' Hl'el:lS lJ1etltioll~d the stlTillJ1 i", lloll-nrlyi;!'i1lde.
<br />
<br />fll ]~l{ll E,IIlSH...lwOll!!lll snit i1!!lliIlSt. ("OIOI'iltlo ill thi... ('11II !"t I'll]" ,III iJlJlllll'tinll
<br />I'(':-.Inlillillg' tll(. 1I11tl'!' fl'll111 di"l'l'till,!:. O/" pt'nllit I ill;,!' clll."Olll' 11111/el' h(,!' ilutlio;'ity
<br />tll diw'l'i. '\.,Ilf'!.... or 1]11' !'j\'t'l' \\'ithill (~ololl'iHl(l. illld fol' ;!'('lIl'l'nl l'('lid_ IlllJl.'flS 1"_
<br />('/I/III"II/!'!, :..!IHi T-. :--;. _Hi.l ]\<111"'''.'0: ill 1Il'1' hil] ;tllt'~l'd tltat tIle \\':l1(-'I's (If tilt, rin'I'
<br />lwd I~t:"'ll 11":'I.d ful' IITig'<Itioll ill he]" ,,-{'stCI'1l l'(ll1I1fi('~ <llld t.hat. Hftel' f'sreJ1disI11l1cI1l
<br />of tl1i'....1-' 11..""_ {'(\lnl'<H1I' h('g"ilH "YSll'lll,ltil.:,lIly 10 Hppl'OIJl'iil~e illl{l di\'t'l't 11IPI:l
<br />II('T\\"4"'11 (',-111'111 ('.l~y nlll! till' 1\1111:-'H" ...li1tt' ]ilw fill' ilTi~iltiI1g IHlll-ripariill: ,lrill
<br />1:IIH]S.: tli:JI_ IlY lS~n, all 1111' Ilii\.lll"ill jIll\\", 1111l1111IH.h !If 1111' llo(Hl \\'ilTel'~, bltllH'('11
<br />iIPll1'lljlri,lT/.d ill Cfl]()l'~ld(J ~l) tllM tlu' ,1\'('I'II~'t' 1111\\' hill! h('l'lI ~TI'lit]y l'l.dll'.:t'd illld
<br />,~~~) filt' Ilatlll',tl M(l\\ l'lllllpkTP.I.,. Cllt otL
<br />
<br />--.' ('OIOl'ild'l !'t'plj('d l-ltilt t]ll' ...lJ'('illll WilS IIllt \'lIlltilllltlll~ cXt:t'pt i1t tiltlC::, nr flll(ld;
<br />111<11". ill H ....tnte of llilt1l1'l', lis bed {'iI....t flf 1'\I~'bl(J ,,",IS fr"C[Il('lltl:-- llry; that (,(dorad"
<br />,lllll hel' cilizt'lI~ IHid diyel'tl'd Ilnd llsec1 onl," the percllllial fln\\" :lhn\"P- C,lllOIl City
<br />ilud ,,'llilt Jlml been (lOlll~ ill (.ffrct eOIl~t:.rn"(l ,,'Mer for lleliyery illtn E:all"'(I~. ~lll'
<br />deaip(l ~lle llild ~nb...;ral1ti;[l]y dilllini:':]Il~d the fill\\" of the ri\'(:r at. th~ ~tllte lilU:~.
<br />:--:11(' HS<';PJ'Tecl she \\",IS clltitll,(l to eOllsmnr Ih(' f'llt,irt' flow; hut Cl]Jc;:ed tl1<1t. ill illl:'
<br />\'/e\\'. hpl' total nppl'llpl'iHtions did JIll! illllOl1lJI In nil illfl'iI1f:!l'Ill"2llt of J~Cln"'il:-"
<br />I.i!-!.ht.... t'H1]ill~ for .illdieial illtedf'J'ew'l'_
<br />
<br />TIIP vn1\l.t denied KHllSll.":' (.ollll-tltilllJ tllilt ...hi' \\';}" cntitJc(l to hfl\'(' lll"
<br />...tl't'illll tli,,,- (IS it 1hl\\('(1 in i1 stl.lte nf tl:llllJ'C, [t I!t>llit'd C'.\]or:Jdo's tlai::n t!Jnt :-.b._,
<br />('011111 di."posP of all Ihe waters withill her bOI'(l('rs, nl1d o,yed nn nldi~'il!irln to
<br />p(i~!" ;.my of th\'m on hi 1\;m:-,~~_ 1t \1C"\il1't'{1 that <l~ e;-l\.:h ~tate h,Hl fill I;'qna\il.'-
<br />{If ,'ight e<l:r.:h stood before the court On the same Jeyel (l~ the otlll'I': tllil1 lllljllil'Y
<br />Wil~ Illlt t:ollfined tn the questioll wht'thel' illlY portion of tll(> ri,-t'1' \\"Illers "'('!'.'
<br />withll('lcl hy l'oln]'(Hlo l:11t mn<.;t ill(,llllh' tllf' pffl'('f nf ",11m Ilflfl h('f'll ,lnnn I1PI):1
<br />
<br />\ 7h.. "'~Irl "v,'rrull'd II l!t'lllllrr,.!' II> 1:11;' I)ill Hllll r"q\llrt'~l C"JIII'a'}" \(.1 all:;\I"~1 h.lll...:l....'
<br />('olflrn,lr,. 1 ~.". C;. ;:;. 12;;.
<br />
<br />.~~
<br />
|