|
<br />I
<br />
<br />TABLE -L-
<br />ASSESSMENT Of SOCIAL. ECONOMIC, AND ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS
<br />HOLLY LOCAL PROTECTION PROJECT
<br />
<br />FLOOD PLAIN REGULATIONS
<br />
<br />PO'~lhle pcon<>lIlc "fhet b...e~ on type of flood
<br />fllain acd....
<br />
<br />Enhanced econOllie vdue fr"mn,oteotinjl;
<br />"ro!>etU". char ar" condudn to floo<l
<br />dam"~e.
<br />
<br />Lh.!, tan~ CO" ~" "o"b" or other .estriot!",p
<br />"eas"."s.
<br />
<br />~o".jhle enhan..""'''''. of nuhlte fatl11t1...
<br />th.oueh ..ddHion of path, recreatlnn ...u.s,
<br />J.aku, etc. ...hlth "rOduce. 'd<lll!onal
<br />reVenue.
<br />Continued d......u to exlstiM fFIII.te.. 11'1-
<br />fl"ence f"t",u Ho"th out.<l<1e flood plain.
<br />
<br />Sa.eas "FloodWarnlne and forecUtlnkSer"i.e".
<br />
<br />s_u "l>u1'>lI< fadJitj,..".
<br />
<br />Inal,,,tfIN"t ..fher.
<br />
<br />lns1v"lfleanteffect.
<br />
<br />IMbn1fl."nt effect, except for alternative
<br />"",,,10"'"'''0' f"uFone.
<br />
<br />~o effect.
<br />
<br />,.
<br />!
<br />
<br />Restrictions M ho\ld!".. in the l1nod l'hln
<br />could u1tlmatdv H.pl"c" resldent.. and
<br />fore...o alternative hu.~ines" RetlYI'v.
<br />
<br />With HO~H flood plain ~e?,J!atl~ns, area
<br />aesthet!es could he ~~..atelv i",,,roved.
<br />
<br />No effect.
<br />
<br />llosl"nifl"an,..ffe"t.
<br />
<br />Inal,nif1"anteffecto
<br />
<br />Salle aa "flood Warnln~ and !'orecaat1n,
<br />Snvl"..".
<br />
<br />5....1' as "flood Warnin" and !'nrecastin"SHvi"e".
<br />
<br />Sa..e a~ "flood Warnln" and "orecastln~_ Service"
<br />
<br />!'lan'sfut"relnfluenceinthefloodnlain"",,,ldhe
<br />ll..itedandthi..actlon"nuldheneflthothnlant
<br />andani..al"""",unltles.
<br />
<br />As,"ure th.. nHpetUI\r1on of th~'OHratlne
<br />ecoayate11", !'coavat"lIs would he ",.Inralned
<br />in a hhhly dvnam1c "ondition.
<br />
<br />"10 i_edbt<> effect.
<br />
<br />SINGLE PURPOSE RESERVOIRS
<br />
<br />Re..oval of IS.OOO .au of h....land and ranch-
<br />land ho.. County tU ~olls. lnc~ua.. in p~ooeny
<br />valuea and Io<:al Cov..rn",..nt finandal c"nahillty.
<br />Reduced cMt. lo~ flood cleanuo.
<br />
<br />1'otenthl increaa.. In nco.....Try value~ ..hln,
<br />local (;oyern..ent "t~onu~ tu haae I\no hetter
<br />honoln? caoaHlley.
<br />1.and 10 the ~e~H"ol~ site "ill have a l""..~
<br />value. 1.and "olncetlt "ill he enhanc..d o~ nm-
<br />vlde a ereater eeOO""'le ~..turn.
<br />"~ntectlon for public faclll,les froll flood"
<br />tbatvouldconyenda"'ave_.toheneflta.
<br />
<br />n.",a"es n~evented ~'ould equal hen..ft '".
<br />SHvlces ",mid continue du~lne flood..
<br />
<br />Posttlve lmnac' onn?lonal H",,'h.
<br />
<br />Eoonomlc I",nact ~oual to h..n..fits ~~ceived ft"",
<br />flood n~otectlon for hu"1ne~s 10<< ano
<br />in'enun,lnn. _
<br />
<br />DIa..la"....eo' of 1 S h"",~s and cn"ld ell"'ln~t~
<br />uo to lS.onO I\c~e" of hc", and ~anch lano.
<br />
<br />f.conomle heMflU ~qual tn c~on oa"'~~~"
<br />p~eypnud.
<br />
<br />~hon-t\me eMnl,,""'''''' hoom fot con~truetloo.
<br />~alntl\tn. If nO' Incu.Hed, ....nlnVl'Oent du~ '0
<br />!nccP~~?d economic ~etlvltv.
<br />
<br />Inc~?a~,"d noi'e d,,~ln~ cno",~uctlon. ~o
<br />lasttoeeffpct.
<br />
<br />Illsnl"c......n' of I ~ farm. "nO ~omc facm v,,~ker"
<br />th~,.,u~h the 10"s of l~.n'l~ acte~ of In,om~
<br />nr<>dudn.laod.
<br />~e",,'lve Il\M ae.th..'te v"lue. VI'ual ~e"tada-
<br />,Ion du~ In? conHruct Ion.
<br />
<br />COMt~uetlon ne,sonnel could dlnup, aocia1
<br />""rtHOS. I.",,?-la",ln~ ..ffect wOUI~ he
<br />lmp~oved moods, atmo"phHe. aod Hfe nattHM.
<br />
<br />Po"ltlye ~ff~c"
<br />
<br />Po~Hlv~ ..ff..ct.
<br />
<br />P~otectlon vould he nrovided ft"'" d_~lu
<br />effect" of flood vat~~ aod .11t.
<br />
<br />Shon te.... "a'H qualltvdeHadatloo durin9 ron-
<br />"truer 100. Lon~-te~m wate~ quall 'v de;t..~loration
<br />~esultln~ f~om Increased 1~~luted a,,~lcultutal
<br />ac'lvitv.
<br />
<br />('ons'~uctl"" ~rtlvltle" w<>uId pr"duce !oteMI-
<br />tted but 'e"'"oUtv '''u~ce5 of al~ and "a'e~
<br />nellutlen. Stcuctu~~ """ld he a vt5ual nnllu-
<br />t"nto Water ~ual1ty vould he Improve,1 hv
<br />re,l<lctioo nf 'edlm~nt, hut d....Taded th~"u~h
<br />eyannr,H!on, .alt In~dln1'.. and inc~e,,"'" In
<br />a~~lrultural usps. R..~ervolr "edlmpnt vould b~
<br />1\ ~OUTCe of aIr nolluU,,,,.
<br />
<br />~~;~~~'~: I :~d e:t~:~~~;t ~~n<I~: :~;:::o~~/:;~:ie~_
<br />~ted dovn~tTeam land-~~e Chan?~5 ...ould ~?duce
<br />""tlve nlant H"",th aod adv..~"e]v effect vlld-
<br />IH~ oop"latlo"..
<br />
<br />lIpland ..rt'svtp'" ....uld ~P d~"HOVed and renlaced
<br />hv b""i,,allv un/>roduo,iv.. ~v5t...... Salin..
<br />toleraot nlantco"""unHl...,",,,uld he..lI..lnateo.
<br />
<br />rh~nnel deHadatlon would Octut Imme~iHelv
<br />oP!-ov th<' ~'~"ctu~... and eh~one} a~"noa,inn
<br />vouldoccurfunh..tdovn"tteam.
<br />
<br />CHANNEL IMPROVEMENT
<br />
<br />R"",,,val of 120 ac~e" of fa...land and u=h-
<br />land f~,,", Coun'v r.~ ~olls.
<br />S.lIe U "Re~~.voIU".
<br />
<br />Sa.e a~ "ResHvolr~".
<br />
<br />Salle a~ '"R"Sf'~Yol<s".
<br />
<br />Sa..eas'"Re5ervoir"".
<br />
<br />~ame as "Res..rvolrs".
<br />
<br />Sa",e ao "RuerYot~~".
<br />
<br />~a..e as "R~5Hvolr~"
<br />
<br />>tlno~ effects.
<br />
<br />Same ~s '"Re.ervol,,"",
<br />
<br />SalOl' as "R"'Hvoi~"".
<br />
<br />Sa",ea. "Re.ervolr.".
<br />
<br />IMi?olfjcant effect.
<br />
<br />Sa.... as "~e.erYol~"".
<br />
<br />Sameaa"Re.ervolrs"
<br />
<br />"05Hlv.. ~ff..et.
<br />
<br />PosHlve effect.
<br />
<br />Sa..eas "Rea..rvo1u",
<br />
<br />S....e aa "Reaervol~"".
<br />
<br />Te..po~arv a1~ and vater qualHv de~udation
<br />durin"- ."nat~uttloo. Water quality deter10n-
<br />tlon resUltln.._ fro.. i.ncreased 1rri"ated
<br />MtlcuHural actlvltv. Inc~eas~ in ~"'quh<,d
<br />.au"e over ether alte~na'ives c""ld oOn-
<br />stltutelandpollution.
<br />
<br />Reouctlonoft..rr..a,rJalwlldllf..habl'at
<br />a~d OO1'>nla'lon would o"cu~ from land clearin..,.
<br />l"hh oopula'i008 could he elfo,inat..d beoau"e
<br />of ~~ducttoo of fhh food and f{..h food
<br />orunh..s.
<br />
<br />Land cl","~in" would e11..101\te the ....io~itv
<br />,.,f the phn' ..rovtb. Ilite~ exlst!n" ..ic~o-
<br />n' ''''''",", and ~envert natu~al ecosv.t.....
<br />lnto co-nnunltles f~eouen'lv alte~ed hv a..rl-
<br />cuJtu~al eod~avors.
<br />
<br />!'1eaoders would h~ el1mlnated. De..~adat\on
<br />vould o<cu~ In th~ prolect area and a"l\~ada-
<br />tlnn hel"'" the n~oteet.
<br />
<br />DIVERSIONS
<br />
<br />Re_al of 1~Oacre"of fa...landand raochland
<br />fr"",Countv turolls.
<br />S...e as "Ru~rvo1u".
<br />
<br />Sa..e "" "R"~"l"Volc,,".
<br />
<br />S..... a~ "Ruervoiu'".
<br />
<br />Sa_u"Ruervoin".
<br />
<br />Sa.... as "Reservoiu".
<br />
<br />S....eaa "Ruervoirs".
<br />
<br />Sa.e u "Reservoiu".
<br />
<br />Dh..l.c.......nt of 4 holies and eould el1..inate
<br />VIO acres of fa,.,. and ranch land.
<br />
<br />Same as "Rese~voha".
<br />
<br />S-..aa "Rese~v01rs".
<br />
<br />Same as "Res..rvoiu".
<br />
<br />Insl"ntficanreff..",.
<br />
<br />Sa....u "Reurvoirs".
<br />
<br />Sa_as "Rese.....oirs".
<br />
<br />Poaltlveeff"'et.
<br />
<br />P....Hive eff~ct.
<br />
<br />SaII>e "s "Ruetvoirs".
<br />
<br />Sa..e.s "Res~.....oiu".
<br />
<br />Shorr-te"" sources ef al~ and vater !>ollution
<br />assodated "ith eon5t~uctl"n, Conc~..tP I1ned
<br />channel" ,"",uld he aeath..t1eall... und..d~ahle.
<br />[)veta]] water ou~l1tv w,,,,ld be bu1callv
<br />,unaffected,
<br />
<br />i SIl'T11f1r.nt a"~ea,..e of fal'1l\land.woods, and ..aate-
<br />'land ..ould be re~ui~ed tbus oeatrov1n" v'"Retatl""
<br />: and ~educin" "i Idlife populations,
<br />l<,c<>5v"te.... losses 'k>uld ooou~ on all landa
<br />~ al ter..d hv tbe p~o leet.
<br />
<br />i ('nmnlet..lv alte~ tb.. ohv.lcel f..aw~es. I1vd~<>-
<br />loeir efflden"v WOuld he hnroved th<>u~h the
<br />: ~ealhned 'ecHon~. and ch..onel d,"vadation
<br />w<>uld O~eu~ dovnau""...
<br />
<br />LEVEES *
<br />
<br />ReIoov.l of about 30 a~~e. of faNbnd and ran~h-
<br />land f~~ Co..nt,. t.~ ro11&.
<br />S_.... Ruanoln.
<br />
<br />S_eu"Reu.....oln".
<br />
<br />S...., as "Re.er..oir~".
<br />
<br />S_e u "Reservoirs".
<br />
<br />Sa..., a. "Rue~voin".
<br />
<br />S_eu"Ruervotn".
<br />
<br />Sa.... as "Re~..rvolrs".
<br />
<br />Hlnoreffect.
<br />
<br />S_ea."Rese.....01rs"
<br />
<br />Salle as "Reurv01ra".
<br />
<br />S.",e aa "R.,ser"olrs".
<br />
<br />I,,"i~n1fI~.ot ..Hect.
<br />
<br />S.... a~ "Reservoirs",
<br />
<br />Saaeu"Renrvolrs".
<br />
<br />Poait1veeffe"t.
<br />
<br />PoatUve effe~t.
<br />
<br />Salle as "Res..rvo1rs".
<br />
<br />Short_te",watuquali'ydeter1oraHondur1n",
<br />a"".t~uet10n. Erodon """,ld t_po~adlv incre.".,
<br />sed1.ent p~odueti"". No 10n~-la"t1n" .,ffaeU.
<br />
<br />T...."ora~v att and "ater qualttv de,radat1oo dur1~
<br />"onat~uctIon. R.,du"Unn io neutIv.. flnod_ter
<br />l....acU. how.,ver, the \e"ee "ould he fn~eb,n 1n
<br />a natural .,,,,,iroll..ent and a.,stheU~..lh ....ac"ept-
<br />ah1e-tos<>1le1ndiYlduals,
<br />
<br />Lou of 4[} ~e~e. of hnd ..hieh reduce" v"'lleu-
<br />ttonandwildl1fepopulatioos. Rev""e",ti""
<br />of p~olec't could off..,t the.., 10..e& ..nd pro-
<br />...id., an "edlte" whieh could u!thOlltely enhanee
<br />fl""alaodfaunal~_n1ties.
<br />
<br />Ilotnef1t e~osvst....-" throullh flood protecUon.
<br />lIouni<ruel'hntorant..l c.....niUes loar
<br />to the l'roj..et.
<br />
<br />""'ratcal featurea,"",uld ~_inundhturbed. 110
<br />d"lrlf1canteffeet00 thehydrolod"efHclen"v.
<br />
<br />NO IMPROVEMENT
<br />
<br />S_a u"Plo<>dll..rnloR and l"out.lluinR
<br />S,"~...1ce.".
<br />
<br />Roodu~tlon "f p~"pert,. nlue" by flooda and the
<br />th~e.t of floodinR.
<br />
<br />No "iltntfi"..nt l_edlaueffe"t.
<br />
<br />kOr>OlO1clo..eq".1 tofloodd_..e. In-
<br />tenunt10n of uae du~ln, fl..od..
<br />
<br />konOl'Olc i.pa"t and exp.,n.eu.0<:1ateol..ith
<br />clu.nup,~.,pa1r,ral'lac_t.etc. Inte.....up-
<br />Uonof s,"rvicudurin1;flooda.
<br />Sa.e...PloodWarninltatldl"ouo...in&Ser..l.....'.
<br />
<br />S_., a. "Public l"a~il1Ue.".
<br />
<br />110 short-ran1;"aff"",u.
<br />
<br />nood d_all" to fa.... and e~nn..
<br />
<br />No effect.
<br />
<br />No dfatt.
<br />
<br />Continued flood1n" h.a. th.pntenUal to
<br />1nfl..enupol'ulat1ond1at>I.,,_t.
<br />
<br />S....u"JI'loodll.tninR.n<ll"ot.ouUnR
<br />Set..1ce".
<br />
<br />S........"rloodW.rnil>llarulrotec".UI>ll
<br />Se.....1ce."
<br />
<br />P..uibl,....ppr...'rovt.h.
<br />
<br />lIeRJItha.ffaet.
<br />
<br />S_eaa"l"loodll.rni~...dr..r...,uti~
<br />S......i~e". tncr.ued Pot...Ual fo.. I....
<br />of h......l1h.
<br />
<br />S...... "l"loodll.rntnll:..nd Fo.....utillll;
<br />S.....1ee".llIcr..uedl'ot.ntialfo..ad........
<br />1.p."U upon..1lk1nd,
<br />
<br />S........l"loodn.1nReltUlaU.....".
<br />
<br />s......"noodll.rninllaM ro~ec..t1n,;
<br />Se.....1ce". ,.
<br />
<br />s..... "1"lood v.."ni"ll.ftd ror...utt""
<br />Sa.....te.,".
<br />
<br />In.1Rnlt1cant..ffatt.
<br />
<br />
|