Laserfiche WebLink
<br />I <br />11 <br /> <br />Bel-Aires that have not grown (or cannot grow larger). This is a <br />significant point worthy of discussion here. <br /> <br />, <br />" <br /> <br />~ <br /> <br />Pg. 114, C. 2, P. 2. We agree that "There is a dynamic interaction <br />between water and plants in the riparian zone: the availability of <br />water supports plants that could not otherwise survive in a desert <br />climate, and the type of vegetation that survives reflects the <br />water regime that supports it." <br /> <br />please provide specific information to allow the reader to <br />determine the relationship between elevation above sea level in <br />riparian communities along the Colorado River in Grand Canyon and <br />the river stage. Figure 111-28 is not detailed enough to provide <br />this information to the reader. Given the aforementioned quote, <br />this rudimentary detail seems critical to the presentation of <br />existing conditions. <br /> <br />Pg. 115, C. 1, P. 2. We agree that "Because of the dynamic <br />interaction between riparian vegetation and water availability, <br />changes in dam operations that change specific water-release <br />patterns would be expected to affect the abundance and distribution <br />of plants." Please provide factual information regarding the <br />nature of the "...specific water-release patterns...". Given the <br />dynamic interaction between water and riparian plants, these <br />rudimentary detail seems critical to the presentation of existing <br />conditions. <br /> <br />~ <br />~ <br />" <br />:~ <br />", <br /> <br />Pg. 115, C. 2, P. 2. The acreage information on OHWZ and NHWZ <br />vegetation are attributed as (Stevens unpublished data, 1992). The <br />work done by the Bureau's biologist Mike pucherelli (1986, 1987) <br />should provide additional information on acreage figures for OHWZ <br />and NHWZ vegetation in Grand Canyon. Given the paucity of <br />information, it seems imprudent to ignore potentially relevant <br />data. <br /> <br />:1 <br /> <br />'.. <br /> <br />Pg. 115, C. 2, P. 3. We agree that "reduced flood frequency (a <br />change in water regime) has permitted upland plants to move into <br />some OHWZ areas." <br /> <br />>~'! <br /> <br />:.-'1 <br /> <br />Pg. 117, C. 1, P. 2. Please provide specific information to allow <br />the reader to determine the relationship between elevation above <br />sea level in riparian communities along the Colorado River in Grand <br />Canyon and the river stage. The information referenced from <br />stevens and Ayers (1991) is not detailed enough to provide this <br />information to the reader. Given the dynamic interaction between <br />water and riparian plants, these rudimentary detail seems critical <br />to the presentation of existing conditions. <br /> <br />" <br />~ <br />~ <br />~- <br />,":.1 <br />'.- <br /> <br />',' <br /> <br />,.' <br /> <br />Pg. 117, C. 2, P. 2. The document states "Thus, daily fluctuating <br />releases from Glen Canyon Dam influence expansion of vegetation <br />from the NHWZ to sites at lower elevations. II Two questions must <br />be addressed to detail this discussion of existing conditions: 1) <br /> <br />26 <br />