|
<br />I.'
<br />in
<br />M
<br />C'J
<br />
<br />CHAPTER V
<br />
<br />.", * .7)...;::;'i'.' ~.'''._ '~-,;,:;
<br />
<br />....<.:,,'~""..'.J~
<br />
<br />;";";-'~l:;&.:"i:a:',:::~; _:;;;~:'f;<:n;., ,,-:-:',"',
<br />
<br />COMPARISON OF ALTERNATIVES
<br />
<br />ECODOIIlic cOlllparleon of alternatives
<br />(Unlt--$l.OOO)
<br />
<br />Without oil shale
<br />Sprinkler
<br />aDd IIurfau
<br />irriltation
<br />
<br />Surface
<br />irrh:ation
<br />
<br />Coal
<br />elllJlhulIla
<br />
<br />With oil shale
<br />Oil shale
<br />and
<br />irrigation
<br />emphash
<br />
<br />Federal environmental
<br />management with
<br />private develoPlMnt
<br />Private
<br />Federal and loc.al
<br />effort effort
<br />
<br />HOP com-
<br />pr01llise
<br />
<br />Construttion cOBta
<br />Dama and reservoirs
<br />Lake Avery Enlatgelllent
<br />Thornburgh
<br />Yellow Creak
<br />Coal Creek
<br />DiversioD dam8
<br />North Fork
<br />Oil Shale
<br />Milk Creek
<br />Conveyance systeJlll
<br />White R.iver Feeder Conduit
<br />Yellow Jacket Conduit
<br />Oak Ridge Conduit
<br />JOllephine Ballin Canal
<br />Oak Ridge Canal
<br />Curtis Creek Canal
<br />Milk Creek Canal
<br />Morapo8 Feeder Conduit
<br />Horapo8 Feeder Canal
<br />Laterals
<br />PUlIlp1ng plants
<br />Avery
<br />White River Feeder
<br />Coal Creek
<br />Yellow Creek
<br />Municipal ground water syste:lll
<br />Drains
<br />Permanent operating facllitiee
<br />Recreation fecilities
<br />Fisbing access easements
<br />Axial Reservoir fisbery
<br />Land acquillition for wildlife
<br />Historical preservation
<br />Total conatruction coats
<br />Interest during construction (5 yeartl
<br />at 6 1/8 percsnt)
<br />Project invest_nt
<br />Lells cost of prior investigations
<br />Less cost of billtorica1 preservation
<br />Adjusted project investment
<br />Annual equivalent costs
<br />Adjuated project investlllent!1
<br />Operation, lllaintensnce, and re-
<br />placement costs
<br />Rec1811&tion and joint-uee
<br />facilities
<br />Recreation facilities
<br />Fillb am:! wildlife facilities
<br />Colorado River Storage Project
<br />assigned costs
<br />Total
<br />Annual benefits
<br />Irrigation 1,540 1,603
<br />MuDic1pa1 and industrial water 4,174 3,956
<br />Recraation 136 136
<br />Fish and wildlifel.! 84
<br />Negative effects -21 -21 -21
<br />Total 5,829 5,758 9,610
<br />Benefit-cost ratio 1.06l1 1.10:1 1.44:1
<br />11 Elltilll8ted by Wrigbt McLaughlin Engineers from Impact--An Assessunt of
<br />ber 1974.
<br />21 Annual equivalent value of adjusted project investment amortized at 6 1/8 percent over a 10o-year period.
<br />11 Figurss shown include only benefits frolD fishery eaaements.
<br />
<br />$14,000
<br />9,140
<br />
<br />$14,300
<br />9,140
<br />
<br />1,190
<br />
<br />1,090
<br />
<br />...
<br />
<br />8,140
<br />7,020
<br />
<br />16,500
<br />8,660
<br />1,840
<br />
<br />97.
<br />1,400
<br />3,170
<br />
<br />3,170
<br />
<br />1,760
<br />5,830
<br />
<br />4,460
<br />
<br />4,400
<br />6,800
<br />
<br />4,320
<br />
<br />1,300
<br />520
<br />1,150
<br />
<br />1,300
<br />52.
<br />1,170
<br />SO,
<br />1.
<br />1,000
<br />30
<br />68,610
<br />
<br />10
<br />SO,
<br />30
<br />68,230
<br />
<br />10.448
<br />78,678
<br />-691
<br />-30
<br />77,959
<br />
<br />10,500
<br />79,110
<br />-691
<br />-30
<br />78,509
<br />
<br />4,787
<br />
<br />4,821
<br />
<br />57'
<br />SO
<br />
<br />no
<br />5,517
<br />
<br />106
<br />5,229
<br />
<br />67
<br />
<br />$15,950
<br />9,140
<br />
<br />1,190
<br />76.
<br />
<br />.00
<br />
<br />23,500
<br />9,310
<br />3,540
<br />7,950
<br />
<br />4,130
<br />
<br />7,390
<br />
<br />1,420
<br />52.
<br />1,110
<br />
<br />1.
<br />1,200
<br />3.
<br />87,150
<br />
<br />13.340
<br />100,490
<br />-691
<br />-30
<br />99,769
<br />
<br />6,127
<br />
<br />247
<br />SO
<br />5
<br />
<br />2.3
<br />6,668
<br />
<br />1,720
<br />7,780
<br />131
<br />
<br />$21,860 $21,860
<br />9,140 9,140
<br /> $15,700
<br /> 17,800
<br />1,190 1,190
<br />91. 91.
<br />60. 60.
<br />19,100 19,100
<br />13,550 8,660
<br />1,920 1,840
<br />3,170 3,170
<br />5,330
<br />6,350 4,460
<br />7,590 4,320
<br /> 19,800
<br /> }'.700
<br /> 12,260
<br />1,300 1,300
<br />52. 52.
<br />1,190 1,190
<br /> SO, $500
<br />,. ,.
<br />1,400 1,000 1,000
<br />3. 3. 3.
<br />95,160 79,800 1,530 72,260
<br />14.570 12.219
<br />109,660 92,019
<br />-691 -691
<br />-3' -3'
<br />109,009 91,298
<br />6,695 5,607
<br />263 257
<br />" "
<br /> 5
<br />227 226
<br />7,241 6,151
<br />2,178 1,603
<br />8,777 8.708
<br />141 141
<br /> 84
<br />-21 -21
<br />11,075 10,515
<br />1.53:1 1.71:1
<br />Impact of Oil Shale Development, Vol. 4, Decem-
<br />
<br />286
<br />52
<br />
|