Laserfiche WebLink
<br />230 <br /> <br />" . <br /> <br />to this paragraph, the other provisions of this compact shall nevertheless <br /> <br /> <br />remain binding upon the signatories horeto." <br /> <br /> <br />If there. is no furthor comment on that, rre Trill lot if stand. 'Is <br /> <br /> <br />ther,e any chanfle in paragraph (c) of ,\rtic'le IV. <br /> <br /> <br />MR, CARPENTER: I think the nards "rrithin' Us linits" at the clos'e <br /> <br /> <br />of t)1e sentence should bo inserted after the \'rord "state" ill' the second <br /> <br /> <br />line from tho bottom, making it then l'e'ad "control by any S'GntD 'l'rith'in its <br /> <br /> <br />limits of the appropriation, use and distribution of water." As it ,rtands, <br /> <br /> <br />it might be ambiguous. <br /> <br /> <br />CHldRi,L\N HOOVER: ,\11 right, if there is 'no objection, vro Trill do <br /> <br /> <br />that. ;,ny furthor comment on that paragraph. <br /> <br /> <br />Am. CALDWELL: I would like to hear reasons why we shouldn't add to <br /> <br /> <br />this somothing to the effect that this regulation and control reserved to <br /> <br /> <br />the state should not be for its benofit as 'provided by its local laws. <br /> <br /> <br />!!JR. C.\RPENTER: The control of any subject mattor by a stnto dortvcs <br /> <br /> <br />its source from its people,' expressed in its constitution, the laTrs' , <br /> <br /> <br />onaotQd by its legislaturo and tho decisions of its courts intorproting <br /> <br /> <br />both tho constitution and tho litTls, That is tho onlY'Tlay a stato may <br /> <br /> <br />regulate and control. It is tho thought evidontly of thoso Tlho droTr thiS' ' <br /> <br /> <br />paragraph that that being tho f'ac't, thostato1q constitutiou,la1:rs and <br /> <br /> <br />decisions of Hs courts m:Lght bo elininated as ;coming rdthin tho ;ionoral <br /> <br /> <br />torm "regulation and control by 'a stato ," It js customary' to speak 01', <br /> <br /> <br />regulation and control in torms of tho consti.tut:Lon, laws and docisiims of' <br /> <br /> <br />courts., But .it was O\Tide;ntly thOUGht by those who had this, _ the final <br /> <br /> <br />draft of this paragraph in hand, that such vlOrds'wol'e surpluagoancl a <br /> <br /> <br />rQpitit:lon oJ the rlOrds "regulation and control". There is some advantago <br /> <br /> <br />by putting in tho words "constitution, laws and docisions of its courts" <br /> <br /> <br />in ,that it is moreundorstandablo probably, and comports'moro to' thoeehoral <br /> <br />.. <br /> <br />. <br /> <br />lip <br /> <br />1ft; <br /> <br />.. <br /> <br />111 <br />