|
<br />~'Il;';"'"I;:l"'"
<br />~ <-'J}:- :::. .~'~.~ .. '_
<br />~".'i~E" : f.\:~', : ~
<br />. ~"r...,..,.J...,.t.,
<br />j;, ~ ..:~:.'. :~:..:'~ '
<br />.... ... .~;..,', ....
<br />;"S:r-::" .. .
<br />
<br />('\-.j" "i.'
<br />
<br />:,,:
<br />}ii-:
<br />":","
<br />"jr'I" \,
<br />
<br />i::~l:;:r ~{~ .,
<br />"
<br />-\;" .:
<br />
<br />~ -,y,:'
<br />,~1:"
<br />:r':,'
<br />,'t' "."
<br />~~;,,:~:'
<br />
<br />;
<br />'"y
<br />,~.,. .
<br />
<br />,,'
<br />
<br />,,'
<br />;'. ,
<br />
<br />....
<br />
<br />....,,-
<br />
<br />'\f'1"
<br />-.'1'
<br />"u'
<br />~"';' ~', -,
<br />.1'l~lt
<br />~ ..,_.
<br />:,.~., .
<br />. '
<br />t'~~";
<br />U'
<br />t%'
<br />-~~,~- ~~ :,'
<br />.j'
<br />"."
<br />-~i: .
<br />j;'::;"
<br />'~;'K.~.: .
<br />
<br />t~f;r'
<br />
<br />\.\~",.
<br />%;~oil:~'!~,
<br />.,...,<.. "
<br />~~!.~ ,'. ...
<br />:>t' .'/' ,,~,"'" .
<br />1/:"<,
<br />~ ;~~ '.,:~' ;>, .;: :,
<br />:l1.1.:I,':..',
<br />, 'l'.~~.~.,:_{.
<br />~;~;~.~' .~':".
<br />~E~::;
<br />
<br />"'P:t ~'-"" '.
<br />~~/...;
<br />~: ';
<br />
<br />~'l{'" . "
<br />
<br />" :'
<br />
<br />*::',~;'
<br />.~\:~ .
<br />Ft;,.
<br />
<br />~.:. . .
<br />'"\',
<br />
<br /><.,/
<br />... .J'
<br />'\:
<br />"~: -J';
<br />, '
<br />, "y,'
<br />. ').. <1,,'
<br />
<br />, ,
<br />
<br />..
<br />
<br />-. ~
<br />
<br />, ,
<br />
<br />. ~
<br />
<br />" ,
<br />"!"'.l
<br />.'1":.'
<br />
<br />.''''.
<br />
<br />:.-~:\
<br />
<br />.v.
<br />
<br />\. ',"
<br />,.1-,.,
<br />I"i,"
<br />
<br />'"The water of every natural stream, not heretofore
<br />appropriated, within the State of Colorado, is
<br />hereby decIared to be the property of the public,
<br />and the same is dedicated to the use of the people
<br />of the state, subject to appropriation'as herein-
<br />after provided."
<br />
<br />Section ~of the same artic~e provides that:
<br />
<br />"The right to divert the unappropriated waters of
<br />any natural stream to beneficial uses shall never
<br />be denied."
<br />
<br />-.J
<br />Thus, while the Constitution expressly protects the
<br />right to divert, no provision of the Constitution specifically
<br />requires actual diversion from the stream bed as a prerequisite
<br />to a valid appropriation. However, the Court is keenly aware
<br />that some cases have been decided where an actual diversion
<br />
<br />from the natural channel was required. City and County of
<br />Denver v. Northern Colorado Water Conservancy District, 130
<br />Colo. 375 (1954); Colorado River Water Conservation District
<br />
<br />v. Rocky Mountain Power Company, 158 Colo. 331 (196U); Lamont
<br />
<br />v. Riverside Irrigation District, 179 Colo. 134 (1972). In
<br />
<br />llorthern Colorado, supra, the Court stated that:
<br />
<br />"The first essential of an appropriation is the
<br />actual diversion of the water with intent to apply
<br />to a beneficial use. " Water can be actually
<br />diverted only by taking it from the stream."
<br />
<br />g. at 385.
<br />
<br />XIV.
<br />
<br />Although the cases cited above support the objectors'
<br />assertion that a valid appropriation must be accompanied by
<br />Actual diversion, there are several Colorado cases which have
<br />made statements to the contrary. For example, the Court in
<br />Larimer County Reservoir Co. v. Luthe, supra, expressly rejected
<br />the argument that the constitutional recognition of the right
<br />
<br />to appropriate water by diversion meant that other means of
<br />
<br />appropriation were excluded. The Court said:
<br />
<br />"The word 'divert' must be interpreted in connection
<br />with the word .appropriation" and with other words
<br />in that instrument (the Constitution) referring to
<br />the subject of irrigation. We think there may be a
<br />constitutional appropriation of water without its
<br />being at the instant taken from the bed of the stream."
<br />
<br />. "
<br />
<br />T~" "'.. Fi1 fi.
<br />
|