<br />
<br />TABLE IV-9
<br />
<br />TABLE IV-IO
<br />
<br />COMPARISON OF lOO-YEAR PEAK FLOW MASTER PLAN, ASI, UD&FCD, USACE
<br />
<br />COMPARISON OF TOTAL RUNOFF VOLUME MASTER PLAN, ASI, USACE, UD&FCD
<br />
<br /> I Mallltr Plan l~YeBl" Peak Flow (cfs)
<br />I ASI' USACE
<br /> Basin I ElelDeot Site Bas'. Master Master NOTES
<br /> Noli. N~ No. Pl..' Pla.' AS" USACE" UD&FC~
<br /> CUHP SWMM
<br /> A. Walnut Creek Basin @S.R.D.C. 139 2 100 m 23 20 210 m 4,5
<br /> B. Runoff to North Walnut Creek 348 3 5 m 240 200 <iOO m 4,5
<br /> Diversion Dam
<br /> C. McKay Ditch Start 135 4 m 220 210 m m 4,6
<br /> D. McKay Ditch End 134 6 m m 210 220 m m 4,6
<br /> E. End of Landfill Reservoir Basin 141 1l 13 250 230 850
<br /> F. Runoff to Pond A-4 169 12 434 --- 650 240 690 --- 4,7
<br /> G. Runoff to Pond 8-5 151 14 334 m 690 480 610 ---
<br /> H. Confluence of North & Soulh 140 16 15 1,700 810 1,610 4.7
<br /> Walnut and Landfill Reservoir~
<br /> I. Walnut Creek at Indiana Street 129 17 16 1,300 2,300 1,160 3,080 m 4,5
<br /> 1. Great Western Trib. at Indiana 353 18 --- m 240 220 --- ---
<br /> K. Inflow 10 Great Western Reservoir 350 19 1,900 3,200 ~060 m 3,900 4,8
<br /> I.. Woman Creek Basin at S.B.D.C. 119 21 39 --- 130 100 470 5,6
<br /> M. South Interceptor Ditch 122 24 51 120 92 370 ---
<br /> N. South Interceptor Ditch 121 25 52 --- 220 210 500 ---
<br /> O. Woman Creek Diversion Dam 113 '" 54 _u 690 400 2,390 --- 4,8
<br /> P. Woman Creek at Indiana Street 108 -- 60 1,300 1,<iOO --- 4,630 u_ 9
<br /> O. Standley Lake Tributary at Indiana 124 31 --- 240 180 130 --- ---
<br /> R. Inflow to Standley Lake 301 -- --- 5,400 5,500 --- --- 5,700
<br />
<br /> MAS1U ASI' iDO-YEAR TOTAL RUNOFF VOWME (AF)
<br /> PLAN SITE
<br /> BASIN ElEMENT NO. USACE' MAS1ER NOTES
<br /> NO, (Oct..19ft9) PLAN' ASI' UD&FC04
<br /> SWMM
<br />A. W.llnut Creek (!l) S.B.D.C. 139 2 6 6 5
<br />B. Runoff to North Walnut Creek Diversion 348 3 --- 31 48 --- 5
<br /> D.m
<br />C. McKay Ditch Start 135 4 --- 33 49 --- 6
<br />D. MtKay Ditch End 134 6 --- 33 69 --- 6
<br />E. End of Landfill Reservoir Basin 141 11 --- 34 39 --
<br />F. RUnoff to Pond A-4 l69 12 107 64 62 --- 7
<br />G. Runoff to Pond B-5 151 14 89 7I 65 ---
<br />H. Confluence of North & South Walnut 140 16 --- 186 169 --- J
<br /> and Landfill Reservoirs
<br />I. Walnut Creek at Indiana Street 129 17 440 296 318 --- 5
<br />J. Great Western Trib. at Indiana 353 18 33 27 31
<br />K. Runoff to Grea.t Western Reservoir 350 19 --- 480 478 540 5
<br />I.. Woman Creek at S.B.D.C. 119 21 --- 21 50 --- 8
<br />M. South Interceptor Ditch 122 24 --- 15 11 ---
<br />N. South Interceptor Ditch 121 25 --- 25 2l<
<br />O. Woman Creek Diversion Dam 113 '" --- 116 140 --- 8
<br />P. Woman Creek at Indiana Street 108 301 --- 301 --- ---
<br />O. Standley Lake Tributary at Indiana 124 31 --- 2l< 20 ---
<br />R. Inllow to Standley Lake 301 --- 1700 --- l<iOO
<br />
<br />NOTES:
<br />
<br />'"
<br />
<br />From ASI Task 06, "Storm Runoff Ouantity for Various Design Events; Table 5. 6-Hour, loo-Year Storm, Present Development Conditions
<br />6-Hour, 100- Year Storm, Present Development Conditions
<br />From UD&FCD FHAD for Big Dry Creek, Greiner Engineering 11/86, revised 12/89. 2-Hour, loo-Year Storm, Future Development Conditions.
<br />The spill flow rate used by ASl is assumed to be directly additive to the basin runoff flow, hence the ASI flow is appronmate.
<br />ASl Table 5 induded approximately 24() cfs spilled from Coal Creek. Subtract 240 cfs from tabulated ASI value to obtain value in this table.
<br />ASJ T.able 5 included 240 cIs spilled into basin from Coal Creek minus 110 cfs spilled out of basin to North Walnut Creek. Subtract 130 cfs from tabulated ASI value
<br />to oblain value in this table.
<br />ASI Table 5 included 110 ds spilled into basin from Walnut Creek (McKay) Diversion Canal. Subtract 110 cfs from ASI tabulated value to obtain value in this lable.
<br />ASI Table 5 included 1100 ds spilled inlo Kinnear Diteh (Woman Creek. basin) from Coal Creek. Subtract 1100 cis from Table 5 of ASI report to obtain values in
<br />this report
<br />No comparison is possihle with ASI because ASI did not include the majori/Y of Sou/h Woman Creek basin.
<br />From "Draft Flood Plain Delineation." Hydrologic Analysis Interagency No. DE-Al34-90RF 57446, December, 1991. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.
<br />
<br />ASI Table 6 included approximately 82 AF spilled into basin from Coal Creek minus 11 AF spilled out of basin to Norlh Walnut Creek. Subtract 71 AF from tabulated
<br />ASI value to obtain value in this table.
<br />
<br />From ASI Task 06, "Storm Runoff Quantity for Various Design Events," Table 6. 6-Hour, HXJ.. Year Storm, Present Development Conditions
<br />
<br />From U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Pre-decisional Draft, Review Report of the Great Western Reservoir Pre-Feasibility Study, 10/89. 3-Hour, loo-Year Storm, Present
<br />Development Conditions.
<br />
<br />6-Hour, 100- Year Storm, Presenl Development Conditions.
<br />
<br />2-Hour, loo-Year Storm. Future Development Conditions.
<br />
<br />ASI Table 6 included approximately 82 AF spilled from Coal Creek. Subtract 82 AF from tabulated ASI value to obtain value in this table.
<br />
<br />ASI Table 6 induded II AF spilled into basin from Walnut Creek (McKay) Diversion Canal. Subtract 11 AF from ASr tabulated value to obtain value in this table.
<br />
<br />ASI Table 6 included 120 AF spilled into Kinnear Ditch (Woman Creek basin) from Coal Creek. Subtract 120 AF from tabulated ASI value to obtain values in this table.
<br />
|