Laserfiche WebLink
<br />I <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />reble 12. Co"llarlson of Conceptual Alternetlves. <br /> <br />4'0 <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />Evaluation crIterIa <br /> <br />canments <br /> <br />Alternative - Conveyance - Historic Path <br />+ <br /> <br />Alternative - Diversion System <br />+ <br /> <br />Alternative - Detention pond System <br />+ <br /> <br />Cost <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />Flood Control <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />Constructablllty <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />~erations <br />and Ma i ntenance <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />Land Use <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />Land Acquisition <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />Impact on Existing <br />ut IIltles <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />Local PartIcIpation <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />Flooding along Otero <br />and Arkansas e Ilml nated. <br /> <br />Closed culverts are <br />easiest to maintaIn. <br /> <br />All conduits within <br />existing rlght-of-ways. <br /> <br />None (See Comment) <br /> <br />lo-Yr. - 52,961,360 <br />10o-Yr.- 53,961,000 <br /> <br />Flooding along East Flow <br />Path unaf fected wi thout <br />culvert under railroad. <br /> <br />Two railroad crossings <br />open-cut is doubtful. <br />Large d I aneter sewers <br />probab Iv not constructab Ie <br />wIth adequate cover <br />(10o-yr.). <br /> <br />Large di ;;meTer stonn <br />sewers wIll requIre <br />relocatIons of water <br />and sewer. <br /> <br />Large diameter storm <br />sewers oUTS Ide of Town I 5 <br />construct1on capabIlitIes. <br /> <br />lo-Yr. - 52,464.500 <br /> <br />FUTure development flows <br />are routed away frcrn a <br />flood prone area. <br /> <br />lo-yr. system uses small <br />dl mleter stann sewer and <br />overflow channel within <br />existing rlght-of-ways. <br />ExistIng concrete box <br />ranalns In Central BasIn. <br /> <br />Closed conduit are easy <br />to maIntain. <br /> <br />All condu Its wi thin <br />existing rlght-of-ways. <br /> <br />None (See Comment) <br /> <br />Sma II d I ","eter storm <br />sewers wI II requIre <br />relocatIon of water 11 ne. <br /> <br />1 O-yr. system <br />constructab Ie by <br />Town forces. <br /> <br />100-Yr. - 52,806,200 <br /> <br />OVerf low I n excess of <br />1 o-yr. des Ign frequency <br />must be channelIzed to <br />prevent overland floodIng. <br /> <br />loa-yr. system difficult <br />to I nstall due to pipe <br />cOler cons Ideratlon. <br /> <br />Overflow channels In <br />lo-yr. design wi I I require <br />twIce yearly maintenance. <br /> <br />Large d I5neter storm <br />sewers outside of Town's <br />constructIon capab Illtles. <br /> <br />Peak f I ow to Central <br />Basin eliminated. <br /> <br />lo-yr. system uses smal I <br />dl aneter stonn sewer and <br />overflow channel wIthin <br />exIstIng rIghT-of-ways. <br />ExIsting concrete box <br />remains In Central Basin. <br /> <br />Closed conduIts are <br />easy to maIntain. <br /> <br />AI I conduits within <br />exIstIng rlght-of-ways. <br />Multiple use potential <br />exIsts at pond sfte(s). <br /> <br />None (See Comment) <br /> <br />Sma II d I o5lleter stonn <br />sewers wI I I requIre <br />relocation of water lIne. <br /> <br />10-yr. system <br />constructable by <br />Town forces. <br /> <br />lO-Yr. - $2,510,520 <br />loo-Yr.- 52,782,860 <br /> <br />Overflow structures must <br />be provl~ed downstreMl of <br />pond. <br /> <br />OJt le1" of pond mu st be <br />designed with multl- <br />frequency outlet ~nd <br />emergency sp IllwalY. <br /> <br />Twice yearly O&M minimum. <br />f.bre frequent O&M dependent <br />upon number of ra I nf alii <br />events In season. <br /> <br />Utnd for pond must be <br />acquIred at faIr market <br />value. <br /> <br />Large dl~eter storm <br />sewers outsIde of Town's <br />construction capabllltl6s. <br /> <br />Detention concept applies to <br />Central Flow Path only. <br /> <br />Northwest dralnageway assumed <br />In place for al I alternatives. <br /> <br />The sma Iler the lac IIlty the <br />easier to control the <br />construction. <br /> <br />street pavIng and curb and <br />gutter recommended along with <br />storm sewers to prevent the <br />build up of sediment In pipe. <br /> <br />All alternatIves require <br />right-Of-way del loeatlon and <br />acquIsitIon for outfall <br />channels to Lake Meredith. <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />I <br /> <br />I <br />