<br />
<br />~
<br />
<br />-
<br />
<br />-
<br />
<br />16 Fort Collins Coloradoan
<br />
<br />August 1976
<br />
<br />
<br />,\,
<br />
<br />,
<br />.~~..
<br />~
<br />...
<br />
<br />~,
<br />
<br />~
<br />
<br />~ "'-
<br />
<br />l
<br />
<br />'...
<br />
<br />
<br />- '~~~-'
<br />'~'''''''"'
<br />~ .~~t:t'.,--~
<br />~J;~:~j'I'-~'
<br />~ - .~~"~.
<br />~'''''''~''';''
<br />'.+i ,,:'jt:~~' ~ __
<br />~';'~'
<br />.....
<br />.,,;.. ~~ ~
<br />.~:~~~.
<br />q.,.~
<br />
<br />~""~'~' -
<br />. .:, ~ .~
<br />, ....... ..
<br />".,', -~. ~,..
<br />"" ~' -""'" ,~ ~ ---"
<br />.",....~~, ~ r...~
<br />
<br />
<br />;~~~~~~./ .~y: ,~. .~
<br />~_ '''' -A . .... ?i_~ ;~
<br />.. .,. ~:~L- _' _ ~ _ -:.,.~:~'~ -'~
<br />
<br />These two photos show some of the damage in Rist Canyon
<br />
<br />--
<br />
<br />-- -
<br />
<br />. ~
<br />
<br />-
<br />
<br />--
<br />
<br />~-
<br />
<br />-,-........
<br />.
<br />
<br />-....'11 _
<br />
<br />'r:; .~
<br />......r'4';
<br />
<br />.J
<br />
<br />-
<br />
<br />-
<br />
<br />-
<br />
<br />&'- ~...
<br />'P'- ',;"
<br />
<br />..,..
<br />
<br />'.
<br />
<br />-
<br />
<br />"
<br />~ . "',
<br />,~, -;0.,..
<br />'Ii. ,-;",(~~,>'.
<br />,." ,'~ _':!::: ~';~,: '," c' ,
<br />" . .w"', . .
<br />-:.-__ ....~~-r:,;:.." '
<br />j; L_~:'\,"--'1:,:~',;;':i,,'
<br />., ,- ,,_.",' .,'t,'
<br />''-<t~-_::'_! ,~,~"
<br />'4f", ~\.,...\: :'~.-
<br />
<br />.~
<br />
<br />~
<br />~
<br />
<br />--(-
<br />
<br />
<br />,....... '..;"--~
<br />.~~.
<br />
<br />.
<br />
<br />F"
<br />~I~ ,.~~ ,": l.~
<br />T ..>~
<br />I
<br />"14
<br />
<br />The 'other' canyons
<br />
<br />also hit by flooding
<br />
<br />private access roads, buildings and
<br />several cars.
<br />
<br />Road crews constructed pioneer
<br />roads tor temporary use, and plans
<br />were made to gravel these, as well
<br />as widen them, so that school buses
<br />would be able to travel the routes by
<br />the time school resumed the last
<br />week in August.
<br />
<br />While the Big Thompson River
<br />was rampaging down the canyon
<br />July 31 and Aug. 1, other areas were
<br />getting heavy rain as well, though
<br />/lOt nearly as muctl. Yet, there was
<br />damage.
<br />
<br />.
<br />
<br />In both Rlst and Poudre canyons,
<br />streams overflowed and roads and
<br />some property were hit.
<br />
<br />~
<br />
<br />w
<br />
<br />tonnpd rlyers that washed down
<br />from the clitts.
<br />The Poudre Canyon road (High.
<br />way 14) had only mJnor damage, and
<br />was quickly cleared of debrls. There
<br />were several rockslldes that covered
<br />or partially covered the road, but
<br />damage to Ute highway Itself was
<br />mlnlmaL
<br />At least one house was washed
<br />away in the Poudre, as were several
<br />private brldges: some private ac.
<br />cess roads also were damaged .
<br />The area affected in the Poudre
<br />Canyon was a stretch of about 10
<br />miles.
<br />Both Rist arid Poudre canyons are
<br />northwest of Fort Collins, and the
<br />site of dozens of private residences.
<br />
<br />The Rtst Canyon Creek, which
<br />runs alongside the road, normally is
<br />not much more than a lrtckle.
<br />
<br />In Rist Canyon, which winds from
<br />Bellvue to Stove Prairie, a four'lOUe
<br />strdch of road was wiped out, with
<br />the damage at its worst between
<br />Dam Lane 8lld the mouth of the
<br />...yon.
<br />There also was damage to some
<br />
<br />In Poudre Canyon, Ute much
<br />larger Poudre River actually caused
<br />comparatively little damage; more
<br />damage was caused by newly
<br />
<br />The story of the Coloradoan's flood
<br />
<br />By JERRY SHARPNACK
<br />Coloradoan
<br />Managing Editor
<br />
<br />A newspaper staff, like any other organlutlon,
<br />needll to do llome planning for what lIell ahead. UnUke
<br />other organ1ZaUona, however, It haI some bunt-in
<br />llmlta. How, for Inetance, do you "plan" tor a North-
<br />ern Aotel ftre that took a Hte?
<br />The trouble with d18aaters Ie that nobody ever tells
<br />you when they are going to happen.
<br />How do you plan tor a MlO-year nood that lluddenly
<br />l'OlU'8 down a canyon in your own back yard? You
<br />don't, Th1e Ia on. the-job training, but If you have a
<br />g~, alert staff, and good guidance all the lltory
<br />develope, things fall into place. Not everythlng, but
<br />m08t.
<br />Thill 18 how the Coloradoan covered the Big
<br />Thompson flood 8.1 It developed.
<br />SATURDAY. JULY lI1
<br />9p.m.: The.usualskeleton crew was on duty,in th18
<br />case Managing Editor Jerry Sharpnack, Au!etant
<br />New. Editor Ron Nonyukl. Sporta Editor Mike
<br />Chapman, Reporter Stephanie Brown and, in and out,
<br />Photographer Joe Novotny.
<br />Things were falling into place quite well. Our ma1n
<br />story for sunday's paper Wa.J a natural - the con.
<br />troversial athletic director at Colorado State
<br />University had resigned. We had had the etory tn
<br />plenty of Ume, and gotten IlOme quotes from CSU
<br />President A. R. Chamberlain to lltrengthen It.
<br />It wall a three-column story, wIth a mug shot, upper
<br />rlght on Page 1. The page alllO earned, upper len, a
<br />Colorado Day editorial extoll1ng the vlrtUee of the
<br />lltate in general and Fort Collins tn particular,
<br />The llporta edItor, on a mIdnight deadllne, was
<br />moving his stories along unhurriedly, Reporter
<br />Brown W8.11 f1niBhed with the. pollee beat and her
<br />stories were in. Nothing much Wall going on.
<br />Except the pollee mon1tor.
<br />The lltaff normally keeps half an ear on the mon1tor
<br />(radio) through the day. But about 9 p.m.. It became
<br />three-quarters of an ear. The tone changed; there was
<br />a llense of urgency on the sherltf'll frequency.
<br />9:30,10 p.m.: Something Was going on. DepuUell
<br />were talking about "warning people up the canyon."
<br />Which canyon? Poudre? Big ThompllOn?
<br />It obviously was a gully.washer of a ralnBtorm.
<br />Unusual for that area, but not critical, surely. Canyon
<br />flooding over the years haI been rare and not overly
<br />exclllng. Northem Colorado, atter all, Ie bulcally a
<br />high pla.1n8 desert.
<br />A story on high water in the Loveland area eeeme.d
<br />tn order.
<br />A "hold" wall put on Page 1: the sport.ll editor was
<br />told to push through his rema1n1ng pagell to the
<br />production department early. We wanted everything
<br />out and done except for Page 1. The neWll deadline
<br />was 10 p.m. It would be broken.
<br />10:30-11 p.m.: There obviously WIUl big trouble In
<br />Big Thompson. Deputies were talking over theIr
<br />radios about having e~n eomeone floating down the
<br />nver.
<br />Reporter Brown had instinctively gone to the
<br />Sherltf's Office, but llhe Wa.J not learn1ng anything
<br />more there than we were hearing on the mon1tor. She
<br />was told to come in, make llome phone call. to people
<br />In poudre Canyon, which at that time al80 appeared to
<br />be in bad shape. But Ute people tn Poudre whom we
<br />could reach didn't know what WILl happening, except
<br />that It was "ra1n1ng like hell" and "too dark to see
<br />anything."
<br />11-11:30 p.m.: Photographer Novotny WILl told to
<br />get out fallt to the clOl!lest place something was going
<br />on, and get back fast so we could have a phOto. That
<br />turned out to be Ted's Place, the entrance to Poudre
<br />Canyon, where a roadblock had been set up.
<br />
<br />.
<br />
<br />~
<br />
<br />./r-
<br />
<br />"'."
<br />
<br />.~
<br />'.-"''''
<br />
<br />~
<br />
<br />.
<br />
<br />'.
<br />.
<br />
<br />-'"
<br />.. ....
<br />
<br />.
<br />
<br />-
<br />
<br />-~,
<br />
<br />.-
<br />
<br />--
<br />
<br />.,.
<br />
<br />..
<br />
<br />...
<br />
<br />.
<br />
<br />.v
<br />
<br />.
<br />
<br />coverage
<br />
<br />.'
<br />
<br />.:::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::;::::::::;::::::::::::::::::::::::<:::::>;::.;::::::::::::::::.;.:.:.:::':::':';:;:;'::;';::::':':::::r::::::~:';';'::;':':'::::::::;::::::::::,::;::,::::::::::;::-;.;::.;,:::.:,:::::':::';::::-:::':::';';';';';';';';';';':':';':',
<br />
<br />I
<br />~.~ II \,
<br />Jerry B1ll Ron stephanie Kat:hertne Jake Matt
<br />..~~........~~.........~~.~.....u..~~........(~~......~w Novotny. Jacobs
<br />..:.:...:.:.:,:...:.:.......:............,....:...............:.:.........:.'...:.:...:.:.:.:...:.......:...:.:...:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.}:<.:.~:':.:.:':.:':.:':':.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:.:;,;::::.:.::;,::;,:.;.:::.;.;.;.;.:.;.:.:.:.:.:.:.;::.;:;:;::,:.:.;.:.:.:.:::::::-:
<br />
<br />r:'
<br />~~..."
<br />t/
<br />
<br />
<br />
<br />(
<br />
<br />~
<br />
<br />.
<br />
<br />People in the production department, where the
<br />pages of Sunday'. paper were being put together,
<br />earlIer had been told to remove an AP story below the
<br />athletic director story, and to move the latter down
<br />further on Page 1. We were planning, without having
<br />seen It, a four-column picture at the top of the page.
<br />MIdnight (tlnal deadline): Brown was now trying
<br />to write her story from monitor reportll. We learned
<br />quite a bit from the radio, but It Wall dllljolnted and
<br />hard to tit together. But It got done by 12:20 a.m. In
<br />the meantime, Novotny retumed with hI.I four.column
<br />picture.
<br />12:40 a.m.: AP story came In on the Teletype wlUt
<br />some additional information. We placed It next to our
<br />story, llubsUtutlng paragrapha 8.1 appropriate. The
<br />story was a llttle choppy, but It carried more hard
<br />news than before.
<br />The prell! started at 1 a.m. - ftve minutell late.
<br />
<br />SUNDAY. AUO, 1, COLORADO DAY
<br />Rad10 stations reporting 19 unconftrmed deaths.
<br />Reporter Jake Henshaw, whose regular beat III the
<br />university, was sent to Loveland - It was obvious now
<br />that Big Thompson was the d18a.ster area, not Poudre.
<br />Novotny had been told the night before to get into the
<br />area f1rst thing in the morning. Hell.llhaw also was told
<br />he would be working Monday, which had been
<br />llcheduled ll.ll a day 011 for him. He was joined in
<br />Loveland by Brown. Her regular beat Is the Poudre
<br />school system. Part.tlme photographer Matt Jacobs
<br />_ who would have a fulHlme job the relt of the week
<br />_ leamed ot the Oooding when he was in Boulder, and
<br />went dlrectly to Loveland to join the other lltaffers.
<br />The extent of the damage and an accurate death toll
<br />were Impossible to detennine. It was st1ll ralnlng
<br />heavUy In the canyon and Impossible to get there by
<br />land or air.'
<br />We had talked Saturday night of increasing our 22.
<br />page Monday paper by two pages. On looking at Ute
<br />sltuaUon later, we decided to increale the sl%e by lllx
<br />pagellinorderto have room for all of the extra photos
<br />and storles that were developtng.
<br />By Sunday afternoon, It wall evident that a major
<br />disaster WILl taking place. The AP photographer from
<br />the bureau in Denver had come into the Coloradoan to
<br />begin the tranllmlllllon of the Urst of what would be
<br />about three dozen photol. Thele ph.otas were trans.
<br />mItted to newspapers throughout the United States.
<br />MONDAY, AUG. Z
<br />Virtually everyone on the news staff was involved tn
<br />the coverage of the flood. Assistant News Ed1tor
<br />Noriyukl was brought In to help edit copy; Monday
<br />would have been hI.I day off, which also WILl the clLle
<br />with Novotny.
<br />News Editor BUI Jonel coordinated staff eftort.ll1Ll
<br />Ute ltor)' rapIdly developed, and photos began
<br />pouring In from our two photographers, plue thoae
<br />from the AP photographer.
<br />The photographers had been able to get far enough
<br />up into the canyon to get !Iome startling pholol ot the 1
<br />flood damage, plusshota of evacueea a. they arrtved, I
<br />
<br />:~
<br />~. .~.
<br />
<br />
<br />':-
<br />~'l
<br />
<br />tlsheveled and In shock, at what became the relief
<br />eenter in Loveland.
<br />A decision WIUl made early In the momlng to in.
<br />erease the neW9paper'. pre81 run by 2,1M)() extra
<br />coplell.
<br />The death count began to rlse as bod1es wa.hed
<br />down the river and were recovered: the toll had
<br />reached 67 by preAll Ume. There Wa.J no Identlt1catlon
<br />~f the victims; their clothes had been rtpped away
<br />and their bodies badly battered.
<br />Many perBOlI.lI from other departments of the
<br />Coloradoan fed the newllroom with tips and IUch
<br />WormaUon all the names of people they knew living
<br />or vtsltlng in the canyon. News staff teamwork
<br />worked. Sports Editor Chapman wrote a story on a
<br />young man who had been up the canyon, but got out
<br />8llfely. Women's Editor Barbara Allbrandt did a tint.
<br />person account of coming down Poudre Canyon
<br />Sunday moming, unaware at tlrst there had been a
<br />flood. Police Reporter Gary Gillen, who had joined
<br />the Coloradoan only the week befors, wrote on a
<br />couple who had lost their home. Summer intem
<br />Marcia Walford handled a wide variety of &881gn.
<br />ments.
<br />HelUlhaw wrote the main hard news of the d1aa.llter
<br />as he was to continue doing. '
<br />TUESDAY. AUO, 5
<br />The Tuellday ed1t1on WILl kept "loose," that Is, a
<br />large percentage of the space was kept open for neWll.
<br />Newspapers normally use about &0 per cent of thelr
<br />llpace for advertistng,wlth the remainder for news:
<br />thl8 ratio WIU being reversed.
<br />Jacobs helicoptered (thanks to Army) into hIgher
<br />reaches of Big Thompson, getllng the t1rst photos
<br />from Ws area from groun~ level, plus aer1a1s. Focu.
<br />Editor Katherine Keniston and Women's Editor
<br />Allbrandt volunteered to wrlte additional feature
<br />stortes: wish granted.
<br />Early Tuellday, It was learned that all copies of
<br />Monday'. Coloradoan had been sold. It WILl dl!ctded to
<br />print an additional 5,000 coplell of Monday's edition on
<br />Tuesday morning. By Wednelday, m08t of these were
<br />gone,too.
<br />Paul Harvey had reported on the rad10 that an tn-
<br />fant was seen stranded on a rock in the middle of the
<br />Big Thompson, referring to it as a modem "Baby
<br />Moaell." Story waswldespnad, but false. We \a\d the
<br />rumor to relit on Page 1.
<br />First stortes on lltate and federal ald for victims
<br />were publ1shed.
<br />WEDNESDAY, AUG, 4.
<br />Our biggest paper of the week, with 48 pagell. All of
<br />Page 1 again was turned over to flood coverage.
<br />Getting an accurate .death toll was extremely d1t-
<br />t1cult, with t1gurell fluctuating all over Ute place. A
<br />Loveland mortuary was to have the only really of.
<br />ficial count, and then It abdicated that role. At Ws
<br />potnt, elltlmates ranged from 7tl ot nearly a hundred
<br />_ with speculation that another hundred bodies had
<br />yet to be found. We generally stayed on the con.
<br />!Iervative side in reporting the count.
<br />
<br />J
<br />
<br />Plans were made for a four-wheel.dr1ve vehicle
<br />drive down the canyon from Estes Park, for
<br />photographer and writer. Decided to send outdoor
<br />columnist Earl WUllon, who knows the territory and 18
<br />a good reporter. Wilson was one of two "outalde"
<br />persons recruited to help u. with coverage; the other
<br />Wllll Betty Woodworth, retired Focua editor, naw a
<br />correspondent.
<br />While nearly everyone on the lltaff waa Involved in
<br />the flood. lltory, lIle, incongr\lously, went on. A back.
<br />to-schoollectlon scheduled Aug. 18 became a problem
<br />since schools reporter Brown was occupted with Ute
<br />flood. It Wall decided to turn the section over to Mary
<br />Tumo811, who normally splltl her time ILl a
<br />proofreader and editorial all8latant (twng, clipping,
<br />etc.). She has done 90me feature work and rewrite -
<br />here was her chance to be a reporter.
<br />mURSDA1', AUG. Ii
<br />Situation eetU1ng down. MaIn stories naw concemed
<br />the continuing eearch for and Identlf1catlon of bodies,
<br />the clean.up operation and planning for rebuilding.
<br />An editorial praised the efforts of Ute hundreds of
<br />volunteer workers.
<br />At th111 point, the Coloradoan had carried 67 stortes
<br />about the flood, and 58 photo..
<br />
<br />THE DAYS AHEAD
<br />With the pace cooled, there was IIOme time for
<br />reflection, time to reassess our coverage of the put
<br />few days and to look ahead.
<br />It was about th.Is time that talk of a special ed1t1on
<br />began. Should it be done? What would It contain? How
<br />many pagell should It be? Should we use color? What
<br />about cost? What llhould It sell for? How would sales
<br />be handled?
<br />At a meeting of Coloradoan executives, the
<br />suggelltlon was made, and unanimously accepted,
<br />that regardleu of the coat of the edition, the
<br />Coloradoan would receive none of the proceeds. One
<br />hundred per cent of the revenue would be contributed
<br />to disaster relief, and the Coloradoan would absorb
<br />the COllt of printing. This was not a sttuation tor prottt-
<br />taking.
<br />Eventually, the dectslon on the edition W&ll "go,"
<br />and work began on the detallll.
<br />With virtually no way to estimate the demand for
<br />the edition, It wall decIded to print the 16-page edlUon
<br />by advance order; early estimates on' l8les tijl,d
<br />ranged from less than GOO to more than 8,000. The
<br />elltImatel proved far oft - the total would be tn ex-
<br />ceSll of 18,000.
<br />Reporters were ILIslgned llpeC1a1 .tories and up-
<br />dates for the edition, and editors pored oyer the more
<br />than 800 photos that had been taken in the course of
<br />flood coverage. Editors looked for pictures that would
<br />"best tell the story" In the limited space avaUable.
<br />While the 16 pages were to contain no advertising, we
<br />had matertal enough to fill a hundred pagee.
<br />
<br />Meanwhile, the after. the-fact flood coverage
<br />continued, and, along with It, the grim body count.
<br />For the news staff of the Coloradoan, the Big
<br />'ThompllOn (\Qod WILl a great newa story, from the
<br />professional point of view. And there was a feeling of
<br />prtde tn the role that each played In relaying the story
<br />to the reader. Thlt Is their job, and, as one reporter
<br />was to lay, "Th1sta what we get paid for."
<br />But there Is no rejo1cing in a lltor)' like Utls.
<br />Reporters and editors and photographers are human
<br />beings no lellS 80 than those human beings who died 10
<br />violently that night in the canyon or those they left
<br />behind to moum.
<br />Newspaper people are not the makers of the news,
<br />only the bearers of It, whether the news be bad or good
<br />or somewhere In between. Profeeslonally, the
<br />reporter separates himself from the event; per.
<br />!Ionally, he 11 no dUferent than anyone ellle.
<br />
|