<br />,.,rr
<br />2 Fort Collins Coloradoan
<br />
<br />August 1976
<br />
<br />Flood alert sent state officials into quick action
<br />
<br />By MARILYN HOLMES
<br />For the Cbloradoan
<br />
<br />Disasters that leave in their wake
<br />the agony of death and anxiety about
<br />future occurrences inevitably raise
<br />the quesUon of the ability of local,
<br />state and federal officials to cope.
<br />Do they have an instant plan of
<br />aclion that goes into effect when
<br />disaster strikes? Who Is noUfied and
<br />in what order? What are the state's
<br />emergency procedures?
<br />The flash flood that surged down
<br />the Big Thompson Canyon on
<br />Saturday, July 31. during the height
<br />of ())!orado's tourist season set a
<br />number of state organizations into
<br />action. .
<br />One of the first calls came from
<br />Earl Denton, the Lartmer County
<br />coordinator lor the state's
<br />Emergency Operations Center
<br />(EOC) at Camp Ge9rge West in
<br />Golden.
<br />
<br />.~-
<br />
<br />Logan R. Rappe, EOC chief, told
<br />the Coloradoan that Denton called
<br />about 10:30 p.m. Saturday nIght to
<br />alert them to the problems
<br />developing in the canyon and ask tor
<br />certain kinds of assistance.
<br />The EOC offers various kinds of
<br />assistance when called upon and
<br />especially when such problems go
<br />beyond the capablllty 01 the counties
<br />tnvolved, according to Rappe who
<br />has been through seven such
<br />disaster operations in the state.
<br />From that time on Saturday night.
<br />the EOC began monitoring the flood
<br />and disaster operations. and early
<br />Sunday morning they alerted search
<br />and rescue teams who have special
<br />expertise to work in the moun-
<br />ta1nou8 terrain.
<br />At 3:30 a.m., Rep. James Uoyd.
<br />D-Loveland, awoke Gov. Richard
<br />Lamm and told him of the lIash flood
<br />and emergency situation.
<br />Lamm told Uoyd that he needed
<br />official word from the sheriff, Bob
<br />Watson. who by law Is in charge of
<br />the operation.
<br />Five minutes later Lamm
<br />received that call from Sherttf
<br />Watson indicating more help would
<br />be needed to rescue survivors
<br />trapped in the canyon.
<br />The rescue mission was then
<br />beefed up "ith Hule helIcopters,
<br />MAST helicopters from Ft. Carson
<br />and Wyoming. the medIcally.
<br />equipped rescue helicopters lrom St.
<br />Anthony's Hospital in Denver and
<br />others.
<br />Lamm, who had been scheduled to
<br />climb Mt. Evans early Sunday
<br />morning in a Colorado Day
<br />. celebration, eancellb:J those plaJUl
<br />and joined Gen. WUllam David
<br />Weller. chiel 01 Military Affairs at
<br />daybreak for a helicopter tour 01 the
<br />....a.
<br />
<br />
<br />Gov. Richard Lamm was surrounded by reporters on his first visit to the flood scene
<br />
<br />'IHE NATIONAL GUARD had
<br />been alerted about 4 a.m. and was
<br />on the scene by 8:30 Swulay morn-
<br />ing. according to Gen. Weller.
<br />The Fort Collins contingent of the
<br />guard had been scheduled to leave at
<br />2 a.m. Sunday for summer
<br />maneuvers, Weller said. which was
<br />prior to the time he had been alerted
<br />to the disaster.
<br />
<br />Rappe added that, under the
<br />circumstances, special MP units of
<br />the guard were called out because
<br />they have special training In first aid
<br />and law enforcement.
<br />.....
<br />
<br />Lamm, Weller, and State Patrol
<br />chiel Col. C. Wayne Keith surveyed
<br />both the Estes Park area and
<br />Loveland command post of Shertff
<br />
<br />Watson to assess the needs and
<br />coordinate their activities.
<br />All agreed that the primary
<br />mLsslon was to rescue survivors as
<br />quickly as possible. The injured,
<br />aged and children were brought out
<br />of the canyon first and the
<br />evacuation was complete by
<br />Thesday night, Rappe said.
<br />
<br />The rescue operations were
<br />hampered Monday by the weather
<br />when helicopters were unable to fly
<br />into the area.
<br />
<br />~ ....l:iAMM.~RE'n1RNED from ,he
<br />first Dight over the canyon ih time to
<br />make one scheduled Colorado Day
<br />celebration - a bell-ringing
<br />ceremony at the capitol. ...
<br />
<br />Identifying the dead
<br />was a 'team' effort
<br />
<br />Undoubtedly. the most somber
<br />task being performed in the wake of
<br />the Big Thompson flood is the
<br />identlf1caUon of bodies.
<br />
<br />Yet, stripped of Its tragic
<br />elements. the work Is an exciting
<br />tale ot a necessliry operation moving
<br />quickly lrom a mak~shift beginning
<br />to an often ingenious detective en.
<br />terprise.
<br />
<br />The work runs on a two-track
<br />system. lnionnation garnered lrom
<br />close examination of bodies Is
<br />compared with data taken trom
<br />relatives and friends of mlssing
<br />po.....,..
<br />
<br />In spite of all the expertise applied
<br />to the task. success sometimes
<br />hinges, in the end, on a shade of nail
<br />polish or a piece of jewelry.
<br />
<br />"We use everything," said
<br />Michael Charney. a physical an.
<br />thropologlst at Colorado State
<br />University and deputy Lartmer
<br />Q:luntycoroner.
<br />
<br />'!HE WORK BEGAN within hours
<br />of the 1l00d waters' passage along
<br />the course 01 the Big Thompson
<br />River.
<br />
<br />Init1al1y the bodles were taken to
<br />the Kibbey.Flshburn F\meral Home.
<br />whose owners just were linIshIng
<br />their two-month stint as the deputy
<br />coroners In Loveland.
<br />
<br />Under the coroner system, funeral
<br />homes in each city rotate coroner
<br />duty in their areas. But this event. in
<br />.-. ---.., ...."... ..-......'1..............
<br />combined services 01 all morticians
<br />In Larimer as well as some in Weld
<br />County. according to Larimer
<br />County Coroner Robert SchmJdt.
<br />The coroner first was contacted
<br />about Ule flood by Fred Fishburn
<br />about 7 a.m. Sunday and arrived at
<br />the Loveland funeral home a short
<br />Umelater.
<br />
<br />The Larimer County sheriff's
<br />mobIle laboratory wtIt also arrived
<br />at Kibbey's to make fingerprints for
<br />Identification.
<br />
<br />SchmJdt saJd it quickly became
<br />apparent that the funeral home and ..
<br />Its staff, along with himself, couldn't
<br />begin to handle the large number of
<br />bodies.
<br />
<br />A~t that time J~ Uwm. a
<br />District Hospital Board member,
<br />showed up. He helped along 'Nith
<br />fellow board members George
<br />Ugotke and Dan Freddy, arrange
<br />the use of the old Loveland
<br />Memorial Hospital as a temporary
<br />morgue by mJd-morning.
<br />
<br />The coroner also began calling
<br />some deputies.
<br />
<br />"What do you have, a mass
<br />murder?" Charney asked when
<br />called about noon. He had not yet
<br />heard about the 1l00d.
<br />
<br />He was joined by Dr. Patrick
<br />Allen, pathologist at the McKee
<br />Medical Center, and Dr. Gerald
<br />Puls. assistant dtrector of the CSU
<br />Student Health Service.
<br />
<br />For the first few days several
<br />Loveland dentists assisted this team
<br />unW Lt, Co!. William Morlang, an
<br />Air Force dentist 'Nith expertise in
<br />lorenslc dentistry. showed up.
<br />
<br />'The initial group Inspected the
<br />hospital and found no chairs or
<br />tables. only one telephone and air
<br />conditioners that couldn't be turned
<br />on at first.
<br />
<br />"We never had a plan," Olamey
<br />said. "We just put this together from
<br />scratch using common sense. "
<br />AFTER A FEW days the bodies
<br />were stored in relrtgerated tnJck
<br />trailers behind the hospital because
<br />many 01 the bodies were so badiy
<br />mangled that they could not retain
<br />embalm1.ng fluid.
<br />
<br />But at first, separate rooms were
<br />designated for men and women.
<br />(From the beginning, Charney saJd
<br />there were many more women than
<br />men. Of the first 100. he estimated
<br />that two-thirds were women and
<br />one-third men.)
<br />
<br />.
<br />
<br />'IlIe bodies were laid around the
<br />rooms with feet toward the walls and
<br />heads toward the center so they
<br />could be approachtd easily lor
<br />examInation. A number for each
<br />body was attached to the wall above
<br />Ulefeet.
<br />
<br />They each came from the mor-
<br />tuarie8 tagged wlth a pink slip.
<br />describing their basic charac.
<br />teristics such as height and weight.
<br />
<br />But Charney said these just
<br />weren't detaJled enough to do the job
<br />so for the first three days he and the
<br />other specialists examined each.
<br />body previously recovered - be.
<br />tween working on the most recently
<br />recovered bodies as they were
<br />delivered.
<br />
<br />"It's diversity that makes lor
<br />identifteation." the CSU professor
<br />""d.
<br />
<br />"
<br />
<br />FIRST. PHOTOGRAPHS and~
<br />fingerprints are taken of each body.
<br />Then every possJble detaU is':'-:
<br />recorded including birthmarks. ~
<br />scars, dental leatures, ,texture ofar.
<br />hair, hand size and whether the earsf."'
<br />were pierced. Ml jewelry on th~~
<br />body also is remcwed, tagged an%,:,
<br />filed lor safekee~iJig-. ..~,
<br />
<br />In all there are 'up to 151 categorie({
<br />01 Information. It tlf recorded both.,.
<br />orally by tape.' recorder as the~
<br />autopsy Is underway and in wrltlng.l'''':
<br />Charney said it takes about 1',....
<br />minutes to perform thj{;~
<br />examination. " ,;
<br />.'
<br />
<br />This Information Is twned Over to.:~ '
<br />the data or "make" section, ak:i:
<br />t.'harney calls it. whlch tries to make
<br />an Identification.
<br />Six categories of information _
<br />name. age. sex, weight, color of hall'
<br />and scars - are then fed into a
<br />computer donated by the Hewlett.
<br />Packard Co.
<br />
<br />Both the computer and members
<br />of the data section by hand then
<br />attempt to match tnfonnation from
<br />the autopsy with Information on
<br />missing persons.
<br />Dental records sent to the morgue
<br />by the dentists of mJssing persons
<br />
<br />-
<br />
<br />The rest 01 Sunday he spent
<br />conferring with Gen. Weller, Cot
<br />Keith. Rappe an:'! Don Eddy, head of
<br />the Federal Disaster Assistance
<br />Admln1stration, to determine Ule
<br />extent of the emergency and
<br />prepare a request to President Ford
<br />for assistance.
<br />1bat letter was transmUted to
<br />Washington at 7:30 p.m. Sunday
<br />night and Ford's reply was received
<br />in record time by 9 a.m. Monday.
<br />Ford declared l.arlmer County as
<br />a disaster area due to the flood and
<br />f ~~:;t~t;~.~to~~ligib~:'~~~ ./
<br />
<br />Sunday evening, Lamm made a"'-
<br />seeond hellcopter trip to Ule area.
<br />He admitted that communication
<br />
<br />was one 01 the most dlfl1cult
<br />problems in the ~arly hours ot the
<br />flood. '
<br />Maj. Kenneth Powell 01 the Stale
<br />Patrol was In charge of the com.
<br />mwtlcation center in Denver. He
<br />called in extra dispatchers to aid the
<br />scaled-down weekend shift.
<br />
<br />THE MAIN communIcations
<br />system was handled by a big pollee
<br />wtIt and the National Guard's unit
<br />which were operating by Sunday
<br />night. according to Lamm.
<br />Ham radio operators helped early
<br />In . the rescUf mlSSlorlf lihd were
<br />pr8tsed by Rappe for their help.
<br />By Monday night a direct line had
<br />been put In place between the water
<br />conservancy district ofl1ce and the
<br />
<br />governor for Instant com-
<br />mwtlcatlon.
<br />On Monday. which was a state
<br />hoBday, Lamm spent time with
<br />several staff members who had been
<br />called In to review his powers under
<br />the state's emergency act and chart
<br />strategy, according to Lee White, an
<br />assistant to the governor.
<br />Those powers are quite extensive,
<br />according to White, and include such
<br />things as expropriating private
<br />property It needed to save lives and
<br />appropriating funds as he sees tit.
<br />Neither 01 -those powers were
<br />used, he said, but the governor did
<br />issue four executive orders since
<br />that time under the emergency act.
<br />One order Lamm issued was
<br />requested by the state highway
<br />department to waive regulations so
<br />that the pioneer road could be
<br />pushed through the canyon.
<br />Under ordinary circumstances,
<br />proper notice must be given and
<br />hearings must be held before state
<br />olflcJals could go onto private
<br />property for that purpose.
<br />Sheriff Watson asked Lamm lor
<br />the same authority to restore pubUc
<br />services.
<br />LARIMER COUNTY com.
<br />'missioners asked the governor for
<br />speelal authority for debris removal
<br />and alsu the legal authority to place
<br />th~ six-month moratorium on
<br />building In the canyon. Lamm Issued
<br />both orders.
<br />Although Lamm told the
<br />Coloradoan that he has not yet called
<br />in all the various people Involved to
<br />make a Crltlque of the way the'state
<br />reacted. "I'm proud but 1'I0t com-
<br />placent about how to run it next
<br />time."
<br />He said that "the whole cIvil
<br />delense system is slanted toward
<br />nuclear disasters and things like
<br />that and it raises the question
<br />whether we shouldn't have a lot 01
<br />additional training for civil defense
<br />people." .
<br />
<br />Powell said the State Patrol will
<br />probably ask the legislature for a
<br />larger command center vehicle.
<br />such as a large mobile home w1tt,
<br />which could be used lor a command
<br />post where the governor and others
<br />could meet and would also house the
<br />mobile radio communications
<br />center.
<br />
<br />He added that booster stations for
<br />communications would be very
<br />helpful because the mountalns cause
<br />radio transmittal problems.
<br />"If such a disaster were to happen
<br />tomorrow I think we could all
<br />respond more quickly." Lee saJd.
<br />While all the state olflctals may
<br />not agree about what needs to be
<br />done, either to prevent or how to
<br />handle any future such disaster,
<br />they all heaped praise on Sheriff
<br />Watson lor the way in which he
<br />handled the d!sllster.
<br />
<br />~
<br />
<br />
<br />.l:J}
<br />-11.:
<br />.~~
<br />
<br />""
<br />- :',
<br />
<br />I
<br />
<br />,
<br />I
<br />
<br />rfefrigerated trucks were loaned to store bodies until identification was made
<br />"i
<br />also are ~rded and compared
<br />with charts prepared by Morlang on
<br />the wtIdenll!led bodies.
<br />When tw~ appears to be a
<br />posl~e igeptWcation, l;tte relatives
<br />of the' ~ are cootacted and
<br />asked to'review the case, including
<br />any j~elr.y and a photograph - If
<br />the ~1s recognizable.
<br />;.Ti41 , -~.
<br />ONi:&:~'iT THIS POINT, when a
<br />relattl'ifil~able to say a picture
<br />resembl~s' his missing family
<br />member, Is a body actually shown.
<br />
<br />"Oq[ whole phJJosophy all along
<br />~ been no mass viewing of
<br />bodJPl\. . ''h1ame~v said.
<br />
<br />From the beginning this process
<br />has been fraught with problel1Ul.
<br />"Ninety.five per cent of Ule bodies
<br />were absolutely na_ed when they
<br />came In." Charney said. Thts
<br />situation eliminated one method of
<br />identlf1catlon.
<br />
<br />Despite the expertise provided by
<br />an FBI team, efforts to Identity
<br />bodies by IIngerprints were
<br />someUmes frustrated by married
<br />women whose prints were f1led
<br />under their maJden name,
<br />
<br />Equipment was also nonexistent
<br />lor the first few days.
<br />
<br />"FOR 'llIE FIRST three days we
<br />didn't have gloves or any'gowns."
<br />Charney added.
<br />He said work began on a couple of
<br />benches the staff happened to find In,
<br />a room of the old hospital. "Gum.
<br />les," carts for transporting bodies,
<br />only were obtaIned re-
<br />cently. And "rickety" ladders had
<br />to be used to get bodies Into the
<br />refrtgeratecl semi trailers until a
<br />local company built some platforms.
<br />Schmidt saId obtaining the trucks
<br />for bodies, also was a problem
<br />because of the hoUday weekend.
<br />The coroner said he started
<br />worktng on it Sunday moming but
<br />the first ones weren't deHvered unW
<br />Tuesday. There are now seven
<br />located behind the old hospital.
<br />
<br />An adequate X.ray wtIt was
<br />another Item that was difflcult to
<br />obtalnatfirst.
<br />FInally a nurse remembered a
<br />physician in Loveland who had a
<br />portable unit In stol!lge and the unit
<br />was obtained.
<br />"It has helped us Immensely."
<br />Olamey said.
<br />
<br />In one case. he recalled, a relative
<br />said a missing person had had a hip
<br />replaced. The X.ray showed the
<br />metal prosthetic.
<br />Another Identification was
<br />"made" because of na1l polish. An
<br />wrldentlfled woman had a small
<br />amount of poUsh on one finger and a
<br />relative brought in a bottle of polish
<br />that matched exactly.
<br />
<br />In several cases jewelry has been
<br />the "key" to completing an Iden-
<br />tIfication, according to Dorothy
<br />Abbey who is responsible for Ita
<br />care. (It Is stored at night 1n a
<br />Loveland safe.)
<br />
<br />Of Ule first 100 bodies. she said
<br />ahout half had jewelry.
<br />Even though individual Items such
<br />as these flnaIIy might conllrm an
<br />Identification, the staff never stops
<br />at that point.
<br />"We never short circuit the
<br />ldentlf1catlon process," Charney
<br />saId. "The record should be totaL"
<br />The physicians also declined to
<br />take credit for any identification of a
<br />speclfic body. saying only that "we
<br />are a team."
<br />
<br />-JAKE HENSHAW
<br />
|