Laserfiche WebLink
<br />[ <br />t <br />~ <br />~ <br /> <br />, <br />~ <br />.. <br />~ <br /> <br />.. <br /> <br />~ <br /> <br />~ <br />. <br />l <br />~ <br />, <br /> <br />J <br /> <br />r- <br /> <br /> <br />, <br />t <br />t <br />I <br />~~~ <br /> <br />ting a large capacity culvert to <br />accommodate all of these events with no <br />detrimental flooding effects are normally <br />outweighed by the initial construction <br />costs. Thus, an economic analysis of <br />the trade-offs is performed with varying <br />degrees of effort and thoroughness. <br /> <br />1, Benefits and Costs. The purpose <br />of a highway culvert is to convey water <br />through a roadway embankment. The major <br />benefits of the culvert are decreased <br />traffic interruption time due to roadway <br />flooding and increased driving safety, <br />The major costs are associated with the <br />construction of the roadway embankment <br />and the culvert itself. Maintenance of <br />the facility and flood damage potential <br />must also be factored into the cost an- <br />alysis. <br /> <br />2. Analysis. Traditional economic <br />evaluations for minor stream crossings <br />have been somewhat simplistic. Culvert <br />design flows are based on the importance <br />of the roadway being served with little <br />attention given to other economic and <br />site factors. A more rigorous <br />investigation, termed a risk analysis, <br />is sometimes performed for large culvert <br />installations. The objective of the <br />risk analysis is to find the optimum <br />culvert capacity based on a comparison <br />of benefits and costs. (figure 1-16) <br />The designer should be aware of the risk <br />analysis process and consider using it to <br />analyze alternatives where flood damage <br />is large or culvert cost is significant. <br /> <br />II <br /> <br />... <br />'" <br />'" <br />z <br />0 <br />"- <br />'" <br />'" <br />a: <br />u <br />:1 <br />0 <br />z <br />0 <br />u <br />'" <br />'" <br />'" <br />a: <br />+ <br />I- <br />'" <br />0 <br />u " " <br /> <br />COST ______ <br />RIS K ________ <br />COST a RISK _ <br /> <br /> <br />CULVERT <br /> <br />AREA <br /> <br />Figure I-16--Risk analysis <br />benefit versus cost curve. <br />