<br />'1 fro
<br />
<br />r""&".-- .......,
<br />
<br />.-.........
<br />
<br />....",.~~Jl'."\""~"""'.I_,.
<br />
<br />..
<br />
<br />,
<br />
<br />',........,
<br />
<br />The Denver Post Sun., July 26, 1981
<br />
<br />31
<br />
<br />Denver & the West
<br />
<br />c
<br />
<br />Ridin' the Range. . . . .
<br />Flood could happen again
<br />
<br />32
<br />32
<br />
<br />.
<br />
<br />
<br />Five
<br />
<br />
<br />BY BETSY HOWARD
<br />Special to The Denn>r Pm1
<br />
<br />years
<br />later,
<br />few
<br />
<br />FIVE YEARSagothisweek,a
<br />terrtf)'lllg wall of water
<br />roared down a 25-mlle Colo-
<br />rado canyon, leaving thosp
<br />cllngmg above th(' swollen banks of
<br />the Big Thompson River to unravel
<br />wreckage and piece together shat-
<br />terl'd dreams.
<br />The da7.ed sun.'wors of the Big
<br />Thompson nood and the stwmed Lar-
<br />Imer County officials trymg to help
<br />were confronted WIth anothpr frus-
<br />trating task - untangling federal
<br />rules for recoru.1ructlon aid.
<br />Those hurdles were overcome, and
<br />the task of rebUilding is almost com-
<br />piPIt'. Few traces remam of the nood
<br />which swepl away the lives of more
<br />than 14(1 tourists and canyon reSidents
<br />m Its turbid. boiling path on the eve-
<br />ningof Jut)' 31.1976.
<br />But weft' another such tragedy to
<br />occur today, it is doubtful the recov,
<br />erv would be as swift. and financial
<br />aid could be targeted for much differ.
<br />",nt purposes - relocal111g thE' Survl.
<br />vors, not helpmg them rebuild.
<br />.Iohn Hensley, dire<-tor of emergen-
<br />cy management for l..arimer County,
<br />explams why. He pomts 10 a growing
<br />school of thought that no aid might be
<br />thE' best aid.
<br />"IF YOU GIVE a lot of relief to
<br />people U1 a danger area. they tend to
<br />stay. It usually pays to mow them
<br />out."
<br />That allitude IS one COWllies may
<br />be forC'E'd to consider.
<br />In 1976, the county qualified for 100
<br />percent rrderal aid after President
<br />Gerald Ford declared lhe canyon a
<br />disa....1er area.
<br />today, Congress requires that coun-
<br />ties foot one-fourth ot the relief bill.
<br />and in two years, that portion may be
<br />hiked to 50 percent, HeIlSley notes.
<br />With a Lanmer County budget duro
<br />ing the flood year of only $17 million,
<br />the flfUlI $53 million bill for recon-
<br />struction and relocation would ha....e
<br />bE>en far out of reach.
<br />"'Ive years after the tragedy, the
<br />bodies of five victims still havl'n't
<br />bE>en recovered.
<br />In two Yl'ars, when those \1ctuns of-
<br />ficially are listed as dettd, their names
<br />
<br />
<br />om
<br />
<br />
<br />son
<br />
<br />traces
<br />
<br />remam
<br />of the terrifying flood which ,
<br />
<br />swept away more than 140 lives
<br />
<br />
<br />away homes and addmg to the death
<br />toll.
<br />l':venluaUy, $S3 million ill aid - 9lI
<br />percent of it federal - was amassed
<br />to help relocate reSidents and rebuild.
<br />Vtrlually all of lhe mont'Y has been
<br />spent.
<br />TilE ONLY SIGNS lJl the Big
<br />Thompson Canyon of a disaster on the
<br />e....ening of July 31, 1976, are captured
<br />III the scrapbooks of residents who
<br />&'UI"\ived.
<br />For residents who had close calls
<br />and didn't lose their homes, memories
<br />are colored wtth a pioneering adven.
<br />ture of doing without electricity and
<br />roads for weeks.
<br />for others, howe\o'er, the memories
<br />are much more painful. Some lost all
<br />their possessions. Others 1rn.1 wives.
<br />husbands, ctuldren and relatives.
<br />Officials say menlal health prob-
<br />lems for some survivors still linger in
<br />the form of depression and also uncer.
<br />tainty for those whose loved ones'
<br />bodies still are missing. "You'll talk to
<br />people who will say, 'Gee, they've
<br />never found my mother,' "emerge~
<br />cy d1rector HeIlSley said.
<br />
<br />will hike \0 144 the offlctal death toll
<br />rrom one of Colorado's worst natural
<br />disasters.
<br />Ft'd by lip to a foot of ram ill rour
<br />hours, the flood battert'd 15 miles of
<br />hIghway beyond recogrution, smashed
<br />3'1 bndges and da.'1hed apart 70 homes.
<br />"WE W~RE RIGUr square In the
<br />tmddle of It," recalls Paul GrifflOl, 81,
<br />who now lives tn Boulder.
<br />"One thing, it sure made a ChrtstJan
<br />out of me. I was already. but you
<br />know what I mean. (The flood) lifted
<br />our home up and pushed it toward the
<br />river, and like a big hand, lifted it up
<br />and put it back where it belonged.
<br />"We were watching Ole games up ill
<br />Canada - the Olympic games. AU of a
<br />sudden, all the electricity went off. I
<br />went to the tront door. My goodness, it
<br />lookl"d like Niagara t'a1ls in front of
<br />the hOIL<ie and back - both."
<br />Damage wasn't limited to the can.
<br />yon, dominated by U.S. 34 - the main
<br />artery for tourists flocking from Love-
<br />land on the east. west to Estes Park
<br />and Rocky Mountain National Park.
<br />Angry waters also roared down the
<br />north fork or the Big Thompson, rip-
<br />pmg apart a ('(Iunty Mad, sweeping
<br />
<br />But In appearance, the canyon has
<br />bounced back.
<br />MA~Y TOURISTS ARE surprised
<br />to hear or the disaster that dominated
<br />thew hometown newspapers ror sever.
<br />al da\'s m the summer of 1976. The
<br />lw~1~, shattered homes lying at rak-
<br />ish angles were hauled away long ago.
<br />So were the dozens of automobiles
<br />perched on rocks and hidden in rub-
<br />ble.
<br />Other changes aren't as obvious.
<br />But they are more lmportant to the
<br />people who chose to return to the
<br />beautiful canyon. Since the flood wa-
<br />ters fffeded, changes have been
<br />made to prevent another Big ThomI'
<br />son disaster.
<br />County officials almost l.mmediate-
<br />Iy slapped a six-month moratorium on
<br />rebuilding structures which suffered
<br />more than 50 percent damage. The
<br />county then initiated a study or the
<br />floodplain. The study determined can.
<br />yon areas that would be endangered
<br />by a flood of the magnitude projected
<br />to occur an average of every 100
<br />years.
<br />But the disaster that hit July 31 had
<br />the force of a 3>>year flood.
<br />
<br />When the commissioners prohibited
<br />mrn.1 construction in the floodplain six
<br />months later. about 70 families whose
<br />homes were swept away weren't al..
<br />lowed to rebuild on their homesites.
<br />l':XCEPTIONS WERE MADE for
<br />at least three families whose homes
<br />were carried away by the waters but
<br />who wanted to rebuild in the path of a
<br />loo..year floodplain.
<br />Thtrty other homeowners also were
<br />allowed to rebuild in the l00-vear
<br />floodplain because their homes' had
<br />sustained less than 50 percent damage
<br />from the 33().year flood, according to
<br />Rex Burns., senior planner in the Lar.
<br />imer County planning and zoning de.
<br />partment.
<br />Officials found that the govern-
<br />ment's goal of protecting lire clashed
<br />wiOl emotional needs of sUIVivors.
<br />"It wu, t '-j'oldgm!'TIt tall." :>;lJ::
<br />County Commissioner Nona TIlayer.
<br />j'7 who won offtce six months after the
<br />~"'_ disaster. She had become involved in
<br />11'", purswng aid long before she was in.
<br />stalled,
<br />An intense. soft.spoken, peUte
<br />brunette, Thayer explained why the
<br />exceptions were made as she sat in
<br />her sun-filled first.noor office at the
<br />county courthouse in Fort Collins. just
<br />15 miles up Interstate Z5 from the Big
<br />Thompson.
<br />"Leroy Graham lost his wile.
<br />daughter-in-law and two grandchil-
<br />dren. Still. he wanted to live there."
<br />she said. "It's not a very rational situ-
<br />ation, but it would take a callous per-
<br />son to throw someone like that out."
<br />THE REQUESTS for exemptions
<br />were reviewed by the county's Flood
<br />Review Board, made up of profession-
<br />al engineers, Thayer said. She noted
<br />!hat- the board reqUired homeowners
<br />to agree to elevate structures and do
<br />additional flood-proofing.
<br />Next, the county used $1.8 million
<br />from state, regional and federal agen-
<br />cies to buy parcel3 of land from 94
<br />property owners who weren't allowed
<br />
<br />to rebuild or who owned undeveloped
<br />land in the floodplain.
<br />The Small Business Administration
<br />also provided 300 loaruo to full-time
<br />canyon residents to help rebuild
<br />homes and businesses in the canyon
<br />but outside the noodplain.
<br />The federal money didn't come
<br />without a fight. At first the request
<br />was denied. but after pressure from
<br />the Colorado congressional delega-
<br />tion, most of the money sought was
<br />delivered - 17 months after the disa.s-
<br />ter - a delay_ that angered Thayer.
<br />"The biggest. most inhuman thing
<br />was the delays," she said. "It was a
<br />long time before we cOuld move
<br />ahead" to buy the land.
<br />"Maybe the nood victims didn't
<br />think. I was as compassionate as I
<br />should have been," Thayer said. "But
<br />w~.,........ul1n'1 havp fMtt,.,n thfo ,1111'1" if-
<br />qWSll10n QK.lney without the tOG-year
<br />floodplain and otbor regulations."
<br />PLANNER BURNS ESTIMATES
<br />the county owns only 80 percent or the
<br />flood-prone but otherwise buildable
<br />property. The rest., wtth tlle exception
<br />ot a'few parcels of state land, remains
<br />tn private bands - those of homeown.
<br />ers allowed to rebuild in the flood.
<br />plain.
<br />"Most of the properties that were
<br />flood-prone were washed away." he
<br />said quietly.
<br />The two-lane federal highway
<br />called U.S. 34 which hugs the canyon
<br />walls as it curves its way from Love-
<br />land to Estes Park cost $22.5 million in
<br />federal money to rebuild.
<br />Another flood the magnitude of the
<br />1976 tragedy could wreck at least part
<br />of the expensive new highway.
<br />concedes Dwight Bower. District 4 en-
<br />gineer for the Colorado Department
<br />of Highways.
<br />Roads wtthin the canyon were re-
<br />built only to withstand tlle force or a
<br />tOO-year nood, not a 3>>year flood
<br />such as the 1976 high water.
<br />"If it (the flood) Is larger than a
<br />Continued on page 32.
<br />
<br />
<br />TOr.,lEfT, Tall gran grows around a granite memorial
<br />a~d a boulder which slid down the hills of the Big
<br />Tli"ompSl?n Canyon during the flood. TOP RIGHT: lor-
<br />inf,r County Comminioner Nona Thayer. Elected co~:
<br />m~s"ioner in JonlJOry 1977, she had to cope with the
<br />problems of go"in9 aid for the disaster survivors.
<br />
<br />~..~
<br />'Wf1"'l,~-
<br />
<br />.
<br />".
<br />
<br />.
<br />
<br />'>
<br />
<br />.'
<br />
|