result of impoundment, the implication
<br />being that the presence of a dam is
<br />directly responsible. Yet these fishes are
<br />becoming extirpated in areas, like the
<br />Salt River Can}•on, where such modifi-
<br />cations are yet to be made. Our lack of
<br />information on species requirements for
<br />reproductive success and on such mat-
<br />ters as the effects of introduced fishes on
<br />native species is discouraging.
<br />Another kind of big-river fish-the
<br />small, streamlined woundfin, Plagop-
<br />terus argentissimus, adapted to life in
<br />sandy, swift, turbid, downstream parts
<br />of the lower Colorado basin-occurred
<br />in the Salt River at Tempe (Table 1)
<br />and in the Gila River at Yuma, Dome,
<br />and Gila City, in the period 1890-95 (4,
<br />23). Elsewhere in the system this species
<br />was not recorded by early (or later)
<br />collectors. The last reproducing popula-
<br />tion of the monotypic genus Plagopterus
<br />now lives in the lower Virgin River of
<br />southwest Utah, northwest Arizona, and
<br />southeast Nevada. A few stragglers
<br />have been caught in the lower Moapa
<br />River (Nevada) in'recent years (24).
<br />Plans by the U.S. Bureau of Reclama-
<br />lion to construct a tlam on the lower
<br />~~irin River S miles above SL Georsc.
<br />litah, would affect about SQ of the ap-
<br />proximately 90 miles of river habitat
<br />suitable for this species. Planning -calls
<br />for flow in the Virgin River tiownstrcam
<br />to be maintained only b}' return irriga-
<br />tion flow and springs in and below "the
<br />narrows," about 13 miles below St.
<br />George (?5). The Bureau estimates that,
<br />downstream from the proposed dam,
<br />turbidity will decrease, salinity will in-
<br />crease, and flow in the river will be
<br />equalized. Equalization of flow means
<br />that, on the average, flow will be de-
<br />creased in every month, but the de-
<br />crease will be less in the summer than
<br />in the winter. Assuming that the Virgin
<br />River Dam is funded and constructed
<br />and that predictions of the downstream
<br />effects are borne out, eve are still unable
<br />to confidently predict what will happen
<br />to Plagopterus. We do know, however,
<br />that Plagopterus disappeared from the
<br />Gila River early in this century, presum-
<br />ably because of the first man-induced
<br />changes; that despite its ability to invade
<br />the somewhat smaller Moapa River it
<br />has not become established there; and
<br />that it is fulfilling its life cycle only in
<br />the lower Virgin River. These facts sug-
<br />gest that any change in river condition
<br />is likely to be detrimental. Such change
<br />should he avoided until some attempt
<br />has been made to define habitat require-
<br />ments for the species.
<br />The Gila spinedace, Meda ftrlgida, is
<br />endemic in the Gila River basin, re-
<br />quires another kind of habitat, and
<br />demonstrates yet another type of sensi-
<br />tivity to man's activities. The spinedace
<br />frequents moderately swift currents
<br />flowing over gravel bottoms at or near
<br />the lower ends of riffles, and is mid-
<br />water in habit (23, 26). In this respect
<br />it resembles any number of small cypri-
<br />nids of more eastern drainages. At one
<br />time it occurred throughout the upper
<br />Gila River basin (Fig. 2B). Many
<br />streams in which it formerly lived still
<br />flow strongly, and the habitats seem
<br />totally suitable for its continued life, yet
<br />in recent years it has not been taken
<br />anywhere in the Verde River drainage,
<br />where it was abundant in the past.
<br />The aggressive, introduced red shiner,
<br />0
<br />Table ]. Fishes recorded from the Salt River, Maricopa County, Arizona, in the city of Tempe, in the period 1890-1967. Dashed lines span the
<br />period during which a species probably inhabited this segment of the stream; (O) occurrences documented by specimens in museums or
<br />recorded in the literature; (X) probable occurrence of a species at a given time, on the basis of collections made before that time or in
<br />other parts of the drainage, both upstream and downstream from Tempe. ~,
<br />
<br />Species
<br />
<br />1900 Year of collection or probable occurrence
<br />
<br />1920 1940 1960
<br />. Native species
<br />Gila elegans O____
<br />Meda fulgida O____
<br />Plagopterus argentissimus O____
<br />Prychocheilus Lucius X____
<br />R/rinic/tihys osculus O____
<br />Catostomus lalipinnis O____
<br />X~~rauchen texamts O____
<br />A.Snsia chrysogaster X--------------------- -------------------0----
<br />Gila internredia X--------------------- -------------------0----
<br />Cila robrrsta X--°----------------- -------------------0----
<br />Pueciliopsisoccidentalis O_____________________ ___________________O____
<br />C"rprinodo» ,nacularius 0--------------------- -------------------0------------------ ----X------------------0----
<br />Cutnstornusinsigrtis 0--------------------- -------------------X----------------------X------------------0--------0--
<br />Pantosteus clarki 0---- ----------------- -------------------X------------------ ----X------------------0--------0--
<br /> lrtlroduced species
<br />Gmnbusia affinis ----0------------------ ----0-----------
<br />-------0--------0--
<br />Lepomis cyanellus ----0---------°------- =---X------------------0--------0--
<br />Cyprinus carpio ----0------------------X--------0--
<br />Ictalwus melas ----0------------------0___----_O--
<br />Lepomis macrochlrus ____O__________________X________O__
<br />,-
<br />Pomoxisn' aculotus
<br />----0------------------X_-----_-7C--
<br />Poecilia latip ntta
<br />~ ____p________O__
<br />Mkropterus salmoldes ____ ____
<br />O
<br />Doroson:a petenensis ____O__
<br />Carassiusauratus ____ __
<br />O
<br />Norernigontus crysoleucus • O
<br />Notro is lutrensis
<br />p ----0--
<br />Pimephales promelas ~ ___ O
<br />Ictalurus natalis ____O~
<br />Tctaltrrus punctatts ____ __
<br />O
<br />Lebistes reticulatus * ----0--
<br />Poerilia n:exicana •
<br />Xiphophorus variatus • ____~__
<br />Lepomis microlophus ____O__
<br />Tilapia,rtossambica * ____O__
<br />' These species were. taken prior to severe flooding in the Salt River channel at Tempe in the winter of 1965-66, but not subsequently.
<br />29 MARCH 1968 t427
<br />~~
<br />'r
<br />i'
<br />~~.
<br />'i
<br />t_+~
<br />~~
<br />r~
<br />~d -'
<br />
|