<br />6
<br />
<br />And, as ever, Wallace Stegner was able to treat our whole regional past and present in full depth and then boil it
<br />all down in a few taps of his creaky old typewriter. The Colorado Plateau, he wrote, is a land that "fills up the
<br />eye and overflows the sou!."
<br />
<br />They, and many others, have enriched us and helped open our minds to our possibilities here in the West.
<br />
<br />III. New Views of Water on the Colorado Plateau
<br />
<br />The new ideas, the many new lenses that we now use to view our rivers and our lands, really are beginning to
<br />take hold. These are some specific actions on the Colorado Plateau that are playing out in different fonns all
<br />across the West.
<br />
<br />The Endangered Species Act is being employed to protect the endangered fish throughout the Colorado River
<br />watershed. Most specifically, the just-released draft environmental impact statement, prepared under the auspices
<br />of the Grand Canyon Protection Act of 1992, will almost certainly lead to a new flow regime from Glen
<br />Canyon Dam. Already, interim operating criteria are in effect. The purpose is to protect the fish and the sandbar
<br />communities that are of importance for fish habitat, recreation, and other plant and animal communities. These
<br />are all resources that we now expect to sustain in our rivers.
<br />
<br />There has been hard work done on addressing the pollution from energy development that bas obscured the 200-
<br />mile vistas on the Colorado Plateau, reducing them to 120 miles, 100,80, or less. In 1991, the Environmental
<br />Protection Agency ruled that the Navajo Generating Station, located just upriver from Grand Canyon, must
<br />reduce its sulphur dioxide emissions by ninety percent by 1999. The Grand Canyon Visibility Transport
<br />Commission, composed of representatives from eight states, is in an open fact-finding and hearing process
<br />designed to make recommendations to remedy the adverse impacts on visibility in the Grand Canyon caused by
<br />current or projected air pollutants. The idea is that EP A will ratify the Commission's work and that the result
<br />will be a "negotiated rule-making" rather than unilateral federal action.
<br />
<br />In 1992, as part of the omnibus water legislation, Congress took on one of the Plateau's old-style water projects
<br />-- the Central Utah Project -- scaling it back, adopting provisions to protect fish and wildlife, and attempting to
<br />fulfill treaty promises made to the Ute tribe of Utah. The CUP piece of the 1992 Act, which in all had more
<br />than forty titles, reflected the themes evidenced througbout the legislation: that conservation and water marketing
<br />ought to be strongly preserved over new construction; that subsidies for water development ought to be allowed
<br />only sparingly; that instream and recreation values of rivers should be promoted; and that promises to Indian
<br />tribes ought to be honored.
<br />
<br />In recent years, we have come to realize the many values of riparian areas and that our treatment of them --
<br />whether through grazing, logging, or other fonns of development -- is a significant aspect of water policy. In
<br />December, 1993, a federal administrative law judge ordered a halt to all grazing in five side canyons draining into
<br />Comb Wash in southern Utah. This major decision may well prove to be a turning point in grazing policy with
<br />respect to fragile desert watersheds. This is coupled with the 6-6 Process in Arizona and the Colorado Resource
<br />Roundtable, which have helped bring people together on grazing refonn and which stand for the many open,
<br />consensus-building efforts underway in the West.
<br />
<br />The State of Colorado has continued to improve its instream flow program on the waters of the Plateau.
<br />Significantly, The Nature Conservancy and the Trust for Public Land have been making major acquisitions of
<br />water rights, to be dedicated for inslream flows. There are many frustrations with state instream flow programs --
<br />including the fact that most acquired rights are junior rights -- but we must remember that this effort is very
<br />recent, still not a quarter of a century old. The marriage of a market system, through which senior rights can be
<br />purchased, with the state instream flow programs is a most promising note.
<br />
<br />At mile 77 below Lee's Ferry, you careen through the spray and boulders of Hance Rapid -- a ten, the highest
<br />rating on the Grand Canyon scale -- and you enter into the Vishnu schist, which is so deep and has been there so
<br />long, and has been compacted so much, that when the mid-day sun hits it right, it looks like vast slopes of
<br />black, polished steel. You have descended one mile into the eartb by now, working backwards into time, layer
<br />after layer, era after era; by the time you have reached the Vishnu schist, you have observed. displayed all the
<br />walls of the Grand Canyon, 1.7 billion years of the planet's history.
<br />
<br />American River Management Society
<br />
|