9581

• UCREFRP Catalog Number: 9581
• Author: U.S. Bureau of Reclamation.
• Title: Final Environmental Impact Statement - Navajo Reservoir Operations Volume II Technical Appendices.
• USFW Year: 2006.
• USFW - Doc Type: Grand Junction - Durango, CO.
• Copyright Material: NO

SJRIP Biology Committee
May 1999

5-2

Executive Summary
Flow Report

I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I

important because flow recommendations can be refined in response to the emerging understanding
of the mechanisms involved in recovery of the endangered species in the San Juan River.

This report is one of two reports that address the results of the 7-year research program. This report
focuses on the analysis and integration of biological, hydrologic, and geomorphological data to
determine flow needs of the endangered fish species. A companion report, to be produced in 1999,
will compile and synthesize information on other aspects of recovery of the endangered fishes in the
San Juan River. The companion report will specifically address issues such as contaminants,
propagation, nonnative species control, and fish-passage needs.

RESULTS OF THE 7-YEAR RESEARCH PERIOD

The San Juan River is similar to other Upper Colorado River Basin (Upper Basin) streams, primarily
the Green and Colorado rivers, in that they are all large rivers with high spring flows and low base
flows, they are all fairly turbid most of the time, they typically have sand and cobble substrate, and
they are all subject to late summer and fall thunderstorm activity. The San Juan River is also similar
to other portions of the Upper Basin in that it once supported populations of Colorado pikeminnow
and razorback sucker that have declined after the completion of major darns. However, the San Juan
River is different than the Green and Colorado rivers primarily because it has a steeper overall slope,
a higher overall sediment concentration, and more late summer and fall flood events. No wild
razorback sucker were found in the San Juan River during the research period, and the Colorado
pikeminnow population appears to be smaller than 100 individuals. Navajo Dam began affecting
flows in the San Juan River in 1962, and post-dam flows had lower spring flows and higher late
summer, fall, and winter flows than occurred during pre-dam periods. The advent of research flows
in 1992 to 1997 produced flows more typical ofthe pre-dam era.

Habitat needs of the two endangered fishes in the San Juan River involve a complex mix of low-
velocity habitats such as eddies, pools, and backwaters adjacent to swifter run and rime habitats.
Habitat use changes with time of year and activity (e.g., spawning, feeding, nursery areas). A natural
hydrograph, in terms of peak spring flows and late summer base flows, is important to not only
provide the proper habitats at the. correct time, but also to provide natural temperatures and
productivity cycles for those habitats.

Two key habitats important to Colorado pikeminnow and other native species that were used
extensively in the flow recommendation process were cobble bars and backwaters. Cobble bars are
spawning areas for Colorado pikeminnow, and the fish appear to have fidelity for a certain area of
the San Juan River called "the Mixer" for spawning. In the Green River, similar fidelity to spawning
areas is seen for both Colorado pikeminnow and razorback sucker. An important feature of
Colorado pikeminnow spawning bars is that the cobbles are very clean with relatively little fine
sediments between individual cobbles. Clean cobble bars are more rare in the San Juan River, as
well as in other Upper Basin rivers, than just a typical cobble bar.