Laserfiche WebLink
<br />276 <br /> <br />MR. CARPENTER: I wouldn't want that to be' interpreted. <br /> <br />. <br /> <br />CHLIRMJJf HOOVER: That is vlhy I gave you that original wording. <br /> <br />11 <br /> <br />MR. CARPEN'tER: I :chink, I aJil responsiblo for the, words "for tho <br /> <br />benofit of the Lower Basin" and thoroby am entitled to raise a quost:Lon <br /> <br />of a doubt as to just what thoy really do mean. <br />CHAlllllANHOOVl'R:' I th;Lnk in a broad sense it isprotty clear, that' <br /> <br />it is a benefit to them if it increases their lowwat0r :C).ow 01' anything' <br /> <br />of that kind. <br /> <br />1m. EMERSON: May I have that last sugges'Uon of yours, Hr' Chairman, <br /> <br />again now. <br /> <br />CHAInMAU' HOOVER:" Unporfected rights shall be solely satisfied from' <br /> <br />the water apportioned to that basin in vlhich cheyare situate." <br /> <br />JUDGE SLOAN:' That is to be attached to the first sentence. <br /> <br />. <br /> <br />CHAJRlIlAN HOOVER: 'No, put it on the end of the, whole, thing. We have <br />dealt with perfected rippts, then we come to unpe~fectod rights. <br /> <br />.. <br /> <br />JUDGE SLOAN: Put that in the second sentence, <br /> <br />CHAIRMAN HOOVER: That would seem to limit the first, I don' t know, <br /> <br />it wouldnit do any harm, - just the flat ~entence. <br />, <br /> <br />J1J1lGE DAVIS: Is it necessary to \lSe those wo):'ds "a,gainst tho approp- <br /> <br /> <br />riators of water in the Upper Basin.'!: Wouldn't ,it read better if you say <br /> <br />"any claim of rights by users or appropriators of water in the Lower Basih <br /> <br />shall be attached to and satisfied b;r the wator sO,'stored." Has anybody <br /> <br /> <br />any fondness for the YlOrds "against the users of the Upper Basin" '? <br /> <br />CHAJRMAN HOOVER: Except that it makes clear what it is talkin[!; about. <br /> <br />.. <br /> <br />J1J1lGE D,\VIS: I am not insistin[!; on it, but I ymu.ld like it better <br /> <br />with that clause out. <br /> <br />As far as I am concerned if the Loyrer Basin wanted <br /> <br />i4l <br /> <br />'- <br /> <br />it in, I wouldn"t object to it, but I think the clause is much better with <br /> <br />those words out. <br />