Laserfiche WebLink
<br />Ms. Carol DeAngelis <br />February 23, 2004 <br />Page 3 of4 <br /> <br />. <br /> <br />. <br /> <br />Attachment <br />Colorado Water Conservation Board <br />Comments Concerning the January 26, 2004 Draft Biological Opinion <br />For Navajo Dam Operations <br />In Relationship to the <br />San Juan Recovery Implementation Program <br /> <br />General <br /> <br />These comments address the proposed requirements by U,S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) that Reclamation <br />expand the scope of the San Juan River Basin Recovery Implementation Program (SJRIP) to support recovery of <br />the southwestern willow flycatcher. <br /> <br />January 26, 2004 Draft Biological Opinion <br /> <br />On page 72 ofthe draft opinion, the Service states: <br /> <br />"3) Reclamation in cooperation with the Service, shall expand the mission of the SJRIP to include <br />recovery of the flycatcher. The flycatcher was not federally listed as an endangered species until <br />1994, and not known to breed along the San Juan River until 1997. The SJRIP was initiated in <br />1991. <br /> <br />4) Reclamation, in coordination with the SJRIP, shall evaluate the action area for potential <br />flycatcher restoration and enhance the projects, and implement projects in consultation with the <br />Service." <br /> <br />Under "Terms and Conditions" that follow the Service states: <br /> <br />"3.1 Expand the SJRIP to include flycatchers." <br /> <br />"3.2 Reclamation working with the SJRIP, shall lead development of the San Juan regional <br />southwestern willow flycatcher management plan and interagency conservation agreement in <br />consultation with the Service, . , ." <br /> <br />The Service goes on to make these tenns and conditions "nondiscretionary," <br /> <br />The San Juan Recovery Implementation Program <br /> <br />In 1992, the Secretary of the Interior, the governors of Colorado and New Mexico, the Southern Ute Indian Tribe, <br />the Ute Mountain Ute Indian Tribe, the Jicarilla Apache Nation signed a Cooperative Agreement establishing the <br />San Juan River Basin Recovery Implementation Program. (The Navajo Nation joined the Program later.) The <br />purpose of this Program is stated in the Cooperative Agreement as follows: <br /> <br />"1. PURPOSE: On October 24,1991, a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) was executed by <br />the Department, the States of Colorado, Utah, and New Mexico, the Ute Mountain Indian Tribe, <br />the Southern Ute Indian Tribe, and the Jicarilla Apache Indian Tribe, to set forth certain <br />agreements and to establish the foundation for a long-tenn program to recover the endangered fish <br />species in the San Juan River Basin. This Cooperative Agreement adopts the attached San Juan <br />River Basin Recovery Implementation Program (Implementation Program) and therefore <br />supercedes the MOU. The Signatories to this Cooperative Agreement agree to participate in and <br /> <br />Rood Protection. Water Project Planning and Finance. Stream and lake Protection <br />Water Supply Protection. Conservation Planning <br /> <br />OOH:;r; <br />