WSP08624 - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

Evaluation of Alternatives Matrix ALTERNATIVES CRITERIA A: B: C: D-I: D.2: E.I: E-2: F: G: No Action Litigation Program. RIP RIP HCP HCI'A/I Legislation Modiried Section 7'5 Listed Fish All Spp. Listed Fish Spp. HCP Long-term planning certainty Lowesl Low Moderale Moderale Moderate High Highesl High Highesz Ability 10 develop High Low Moderale High High High High Low High Prelisting agreements Lowest L9W Moderale Low Moderale Moderate High Low High Effectiveness in avoiding or resolving findings of adverse mod, to crilical Lowest Low Moderate Moderate High High Highest High Highest habitat and/or jeopardy opinions Ability to obtain incidental luke Moderale Lowest Moderate Moderate Moderate High H ighes! Moderate Highesl Ability to coordinate or reduce need Lowest Low Moderate Moderate High High High Moderate Highest for actions of other parties Influencing outcome of the compliance Lowest Low Moderate Moderate Moderate High Highest Moderate Highest process Estimate cost to develop (milli\ln $) Uncertain ,5-lIcase 1.948 3 3,75 5 7,5 1.02 7,5 Estimate time to develop 50 years 50 ycars 2 years 3 years 3'Il years 4 years 5 years 3 years 5 years Estimate cost to implement (million $) Uncertain Uncertain Uncertain 142.5 175 142,5 185 142,5 185 Estimate time to implemcnt 50 years 50 years 50 years 50 years 50 years 50 years 50 years 50 years 50 years Prccedent High Low High High High Moderate Moderate High Moderate Authority High Moderate High High High High High High High Pro\'ision of current operational Low Lowest Moderate Moderaze Moderate High Highest High Highest f1exihility Provision of future operational Lowesl Low Moderate Moderate Moderale High High High High f1exihility Cel1ainty duriug plan development Low Lowes! Moderate Moderale Moderate High High Low High Ahility to Del'c1op a Comprehcnsive, Low Low Moderate High High High Highesl High Highest Coordinated Conser\'ation Strategy